A complex index of refraction is essential for accurately describing the behavior of absorbing materials, where the electric field diminishes in amplitude as it propagates. This concept is particularly relevant for imperfect conductors and lossy dielectrics, where light penetration is limited to a certain depth known as the skin depth. Complex indices also apply to systems like dilute atomic vapors, highlighting the attenuation of light in such media. The discussion raises questions about the implications of using complex versus real indices in optical laws, such as Snell's law, and the relationship between the optical index and dielectric function. Overall, the complexity of these formulations complicates the understanding of optical phenomena.