Why is the universal gas constant a constant?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the ideal gas law, expressed as PV=nRT, where R is the universal gas constant. It highlights the misconception that R changes when the values of pressure (P), volume (V), amount of gas (n), or temperature (T) are altered. The key point is that these variables are interdependent; changing one will inherently affect the others, ensuring that R remains constant. This relationship is supported by Boyle's Law and Charles' Law, which describe the proportional relationships between these variables under specific conditions. The ideal gas law synthesizes these observations, allowing for practical applications in gas behavior. The conversation also clarifies that individual gas laws are useful, but their combination into the ideal gas law provides a more comprehensive framework for understanding gas dynamics. Experimental contexts, such as using a syringe, illustrate how pressure can be maintained constant during temperature changes, further solidifying the concepts discussed.
opus
Gold Member
Messages
717
Reaction score
131
The ideal gas law is given as ##PV=nRT## where ##R## is said to be the universal gas constant equal to ##0.082056\frac{L⋅atm}{mol⋅K}##. ##R## is said to be a constant, and thus cannot change even if we change the values of ##P,V,n,T##.
I don't see how this is possible, because the way we found ##R## to begin with is to take certain values of ##P,V,n,T## and then solve for ##R##. So it seems like if we were to change any of them, ##R## would need to change as well.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
opus said:
The ideal gas law is given as ##PV=nRT## where ##R## is said to be the universal gas constant equal to ##0.082056\frac{L⋅atm}{mol⋅K}##. ##R## is said to be a constant, and thus cannot change even if we change the values of ##P,V,n,T##.
I don't see how this is possible, because the way we found ##R## to begin with is to take certain values of ##P,V,n,T## and then solve for ##R##. So it seems like if we were to change any of them, ##R## would need to change as well.

The point is that you can't change just one of P,V,n,T without one of the others changing. Suppose I take a fixed quantity of gas in a container of fixed size, for example. If I heat it up to change T, P will change as well by the same fraction. So if you take some other set of P,V,n,T and solve for R, you will always get the same R. This is what the ideal gas law says, and it is true to a high degree of accuracy in most circumstances.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
Boyle's law says that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas kept at a fixed temperature, pressure and volume are inversely proportional.
Charles' law says that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas kept at a fixed pressure, temperature and volume are directly proportional.
These are experimental observations. You put them together to get the ideal gas law that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas the product of pressure and volume are proportional to the temperature. This means you can write pV = C T, where C is the constant of proportionality that contains the fixed amount of gas. If you express this amount of gas as number of molecules N, then C = Nk, where k is the Boltzmann constant. If you express this amount of gas as number of moles n, then C = nR, where R is the gas constant.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
phyzguy said:
without one of the others changing
Ohh ok. That was a key part I missed. So then if we change one, there will be a corresponding change in the others so that ##R## remains the same no matter what we change? So for example, according to Charle's Law, at a constant pressure, temperature and volume are directly proportional. So if I increase the temperature, the volume will increase proportionally and as such, ##R## would remain the same?
 
kuruman said:
Boyle's law says that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas kept at a fixed temperature, pressure and volume are inversely proportional.
Charles' law says that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas kept at a fixed pressure, temperature and volume are directly proportional.
These are experimental observations. You put them together to get the ideal gas law that for a fixed amount of an ideal gas the product of pressure and volume are proportional to the temperature. This means you can write pV = C T, where C is the constant of proportionality that contains the fixed amount of gas. If you express this amount of gas as number of molecules N, then C = Nk, where k is the Boltzmann constant. If you express this amount of gas as number of moles n, then C = nR, where R is the gas constant.
Ok that makes more sense too in knowing that the Ideal Gas Law is a combination of those. I was confused at seeing things like "at a constant pressure" for Charle's Law because I couldn't imagine how you could increase the temperature without affecting the pressure. So then, are the individual laws such as Charles', Boyle's, Gay-Lussac's not very useful, but when combined into the Ideal Gas Law, then we can start to do something useful?
 
opus said:
Ok that makes more sense too in knowing that the Ideal Gas Law is a combination of those. I was confused at seeing things like "at a constant pressure" for Charle's Law because I couldn't imagine how you could increase the temperature without affecting the pressure. So then, are the individual laws such as Charles', Boyle's, Gay-Lussac's not very useful, but when combined into the Ideal Gas Law, then we can start to do something useful?
Yes.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
kuruman said:
Yes.
Thanks!
 
opus said:
I was confused at seeing things like "at a constant pressure" for Charle's Law because I couldn't imagine how you could increase the temperature without affecting the pressure.

If you work with a syringe and you don't block the piston movement you can safely assume the pressure inside is always identical to the pressure outside. As long as the pressure outside doesn't change (which is true if you do the experiment reasonably fast) you work at a "constant pressure", no matter if you heat or cool the gas inside the syringe.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
Borek said:
If you work with a syringe and you don't block the piston movement you can safely assume the pressure inside is always identical to the pressure outside. As long as the pressure outside doesn't change (which is true if you do the experiment reasonably fast) you work at a "constant pressure", no matter if you heat or cool the gas inside the syringe.
Cool! That makes sense. I don't have to take the Chem lab so I haven't had any experimental experiences like that. Kind of a bummer!
 
Back
Top