Why is there a difference in kinetic energy among water molecules?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the unequal distribution of kinetic energy among water molecules, emphasizing that this phenomenon is not unique to water but applies to all molecular systems. Molecules continuously collide and exchange kinetic energy, resulting in variations in individual speeds while maintaining constant total energy. A key point raised is the kinetic energy of surface molecules compared to those in the bulk. While some argue that surface molecules possess more kinetic energy due to their interactions with surrounding molecules, others counter that surface molecules may actually experience lower temperatures due to evaporative cooling. The concept of surface energy is introduced, indicating that while there is a slight difference in energy between surface and bulk molecules, it does not significantly affect their average kinetic energy. Overall, the average kinetic energy remains relatively consistent regardless of a molecule's position in the water.
Elsa1234
Messages
47
Reaction score
2
why's there unequal distribution of kinetic energy in water molecules?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Because that's the way it is - there is always some distribution of energies of molecules, it doesn't hold for water only. Molecules collide all the time, partially exchanging their kinetic energies. Some get faster, some get slower in the process. Total energy stays constant, but individual speeds/energies don't.

See for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell–Boltzmann_statistics
 
Borek said:
Because that's the way it is - there is always some distribution of energies of molecules, it doesn't hold for water only. Molecules collide all the time, partially exchanging their kinetic energies. Some get faster, some get slower in the process. Total energy stays constant, but individual speeds/energies don't.

See for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell–Boltzmann_statistics
Why do the surface molecules have more kinetic energy than the other molecules?
 
Why do you think they do?
 
Elsa1234 said:
Why do the surface molecules have more kinetic energy than the other molecules?

Is this even true in the first place? If anything would expect surface molecules to have a lower temperature because of evaporative cooling.
 
Borek said:
Why do you think they do?
I think because the lower bulk of water is not free to move around and due to movement hindrance by the upper molecules their energy gets transferred to the surface.
 
Nope - if anything, the more pronounced effect will be the one suggested by Ygg.

There exists a phenomenon called surface energy, and yes, the total energy of a molecule on the surface is slightly different from the total energy of a molecule in the bulk. But the difference is pretty small and not directly related to the kinetic energy of the molecules. As a first approximation (and a quite good one), average kinetic energy of the molecule doesn't depend on whether it is in the bulk or on the surface.
 
Back
Top