- #1
tomkoolen
- 39
- 1
Hello everyone,
This may seem like a weird question, but today I had a discussion with my teacher in which I won't give up so easily.
There was a test question that went like this:
"A + 2 H+ + 2 e- ---> B
Use this half-reaction to define whether A is a reducing agent or an oxidizing agent."
My answer:
"A is an oxidizing agent because it is reduced itself."
My teacher won't give me points for this because he feels the answer should be: "A is an oxidizing agent because it accepts electrons." which is exactly the same thing as my answer, except for the fact that my answer uses a term which puts the stress on the fact that that electron acception can be regarded as the reduction of that species.
Could anyone come up with another argument supporting my answer?
Thanks in advance!
This may seem like a weird question, but today I had a discussion with my teacher in which I won't give up so easily.
There was a test question that went like this:
"A + 2 H+ + 2 e- ---> B
Use this half-reaction to define whether A is a reducing agent or an oxidizing agent."
My answer:
"A is an oxidizing agent because it is reduced itself."
My teacher won't give me points for this because he feels the answer should be: "A is an oxidizing agent because it accepts electrons." which is exactly the same thing as my answer, except for the fact that my answer uses a term which puts the stress on the fact that that electron acception can be regarded as the reduction of that species.
Could anyone come up with another argument supporting my answer?
Thanks in advance!
Last edited:
