Simultaneous trigonometric equations

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ry122
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Trigonometric
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving simultaneous trigonometric equations involving cosine and sine functions. A user seeks help with equations that involve the variable 'b' and the angle 'theta,' resulting in confusion over the correct method to eliminate 'theta' and simplify the equations. Participants suggest using the identity cos²(theta) + sin²(theta) = 1 and emphasize the importance of squaring the equations before adding them. Missteps in algebraic manipulation and the interpretation of terms are highlighted, with guidance provided on how to correctly approach the problem. The conversation concludes with an emphasis on verifying solutions by substituting values back into the original equations.
Ry122
Messages
563
Reaction score
2
0=-85.7cos(theta)+bcos30-85.7
0=-85.7sin(theta)+bsin30
Can someone please tell me what I am doing wrong.
theta=sin^-1(bsin30/85.7)
then sub that into the first equation.
I then solved the equation on my calculator and it gave me 9999999999 which i know is wrong.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Are you trying to solve the equation for b or theta? It's hard to tell.
 
i am trying to solve it for b
 
Hi Ry122! :smile:

Hint: eliminate θ by using cos²θ + sin²θ = 1. :smile:
 
Move the theta terms in both equations to the left hand side.

Square both equations.

Add the two that you get, now you can use tiny-tim's trick.

What you have left is a quadratic in b, solve it. I'm guessing somewhere along the way you assumed that b > 0 since every else you explicitly took care of the signs, you can use this to throw away a spurious solution if that is the case (leaving you with only one value for b).

Now take either one of the two original equations and plug b into it, and then solve for theta.

Ok that was a complete set of instructions instead of a hint, but this is after all just mathematical gymnastics and not a meaningful exercise.
 
Is this right?
(85.7cos(theta)+85.7sin(theta)=bcos30-85.7+bsin30)^2
7344.49cos^2(theta)+7344.49sin^2(theta)=b^2cos^2(90)-(85.7)^2+b^2sin90
1=(b^2cos^2(90)-(85.7)^2+b^2sin90)/7344.49x7344.49
 
Last edited:
i can't solve it because there's still a cos^2 and a sin^2. how do i get rid of them?
 
Ry122 said:
Is this right?
(85.7cos(theta)+85.7sin(theta)=bcos30-85.7+bsin30)^2
7344.49cos^2(theta)+7344.49sin^2(theta)=b^2cos^2(90)-(85.7)^2+b^2sin90
1=(b^2cos^2(90)-(85.7)^2+b^2sin90)/7344.49x7344.49

No no no … you added, and then squared. :frown:

(btw, why didn't you just copy my θs and ²s … it makes reading much easier?)

Square first, then add!

Try again! :smile:
 
(85.7)²cos²θ=b²cos²90-(85.7)²
(85.7)²sin²θ=b²sin²90

(85.7)²cos²θ+(85.7)²sin²θ=b²cos²90-(85.7)²+b²sin²90
this is the same isn't it? or am i adding incorrectly?
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Ry122 said:
(85.7)²cos²θ=b²cos²90-(85.7)²
(85.7)²sin²θ=b²sin²90

(85.7)²cos²θ+(85.7)²sin²θ=b²cos²90-(85.7)²+b²sin²90
this is the same isn't it?

No no no … you've put (bcos30 - 85.7)² = (bcos30)² - (85.7)². :cry:

What should it be?

And simplify the left-hand side … that was the whole point … ! :smile:

(oh, and (bcos30)² is b²cos²30. not b²cos²90 :rolleyes:)
 
  • #11
should it be
bcos30=b.866
(b)²(.866)²

should - (85.7)² be (-85.7)^2?
 
Last edited:
  • #12
sorry i understand what you are saying now
 
  • #13
Hi Ry122! :smile:

Are you ok now on this?

If so, hit "[SOLVED]" under "Thread Tools" on the menu bar. :smile:
 
  • #14
I still need some help.
(85.7cos(theta))²=(bcos30-85.7)² eq1
(85.7sin(theta))²=(bsin30)² eq2
85.7²cos²(theta)=b²cos²30-85.7bcos30-85.7bcos30+85.7² eq1
simplified
85.7²cos²(theta)=b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²
eq2
(85.7sin(theta))²=(bsin30)²
85.7²sin²(theta)=b²sin²30

add them
85.7²sin²(theta)+85.7²cos²(theta)=b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²
sin²(theta)+cos²(theta)=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4
1=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4
Is this correct?
I don't know how to solve it with that sin squared and cos squared still in there.
 
Last edited:
  • #15
ok i solved it. I got 39.152. Can someone please tell me if this is the correct answer? It would be greatly appreciated.
 
  • #16
If you have values for both b and theta, then just check it yourself-- plug into both equations, if both equations are valid then you found the correct solution.
 
  • #17
Ry122 said:
85.7²sin²(theta)+85.7²cos²(theta)=b²sin²30+b²cos²3 0-171.4bcos30+85.7²
sin²(theta)+cos²(theta)=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4
1=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4
Is this correct?

Hi Ry122! :smile:

Sorry … no!

First, where did your "^4" come from??

Second, the whole point of adding equal amounts of cos²θ and sin²θ (btw, why did you stop copy-and-pasting the ²θ?) was so that you could replace cos²θ + sin²θ by 1 in the very next line!

Then you get 85.7² on both sides, so they cancel out (in this case … they wouldn't normally).

Try again! :smile:
 
  • #18
First, where did your "^4" come from??

i had to get rid of the 2 85.7² on the left side so i moved them to the denominator on the right side 85.7²sin²(theta)+85.7²cos²(theta)=b²sin²30+b²cos²3 0-171.4bcos30+85.7²85.7² x 85.7² = 85.7^4

sin²(theta)+cos²(theta)=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4

then use the identity

1=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Ry122 said:
85.7²sin²(theta)+85.7²cos²(theta)=b²sin²30+b²cos²3 0-171.4bcos30+85.7²

85.7² x 85.7² = 85.7^4

sin²(theta)+cos²(theta)=(b²sin²30+b²cos²30-171.4bcos30+85.7²)/(85.7)^4

Nooo … it should only be /(85.7)² at the end! :rolleyes:

Now try it! :smile:
 
  • #20
can you tell me why?
 
  • #21
erm … 'cos you've got (85.7)² on the left, multiplied by something, plus (85.7)² multiplied by something else … that's only one factor of (85.7)². :smile:

Where did you think the 85.7² x 85.7² came from? :confused:
 
  • #22
so are you saying this is wrong?
5x²+10x²=15/1
5x²+10=15/1 x x²
5+10=15/1 x x² x x²
 
Last edited:
  • #23
Ry122 said:
so are you saying this is wrong?
5x²+10x²=15/1
5x²+10=15/1 x x²
5+10=15/1 x x² x x²

Hi Ry122! :smile:

Yes, and yes². :redface:

(btw, couldn' you have used some letter other than x? :rolleyes:)

Suppose x = 2.

Then 5x²+10x² = 5.4 + 10.4 = 20 + 40 = 60, which we could also write:
5x²+10x² = (5 + 10)x² = 15x² = 15.4 = 60.

If we divide by x², we must divide the whole of each side of the equation by x².

We can't just divide part of it … it simply doesn't work!

(of course, it does work if you put x = 1 ! :smile:)

Then we get (5x²+10x²)/x² = 60/x²,
which obviously we simplify to:
5 + 10 = 60/x², = 60/4 = 15. :smile:

Your way doesn't work: 5x²+10 = 5.4 + 10 = 30, which is not 60/4, and 5 + 10 is not 60/4x4. :redface:
 
Back
Top