1st Moment of Area, Double Integrals

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
simpsoncan2
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hello I am in a statics course and am having difficulty solving a problem. In this problem I am supposed to find the 1st moment of the area. I have attached some photos of the work I have completed but it differs from the way my professor does these problems.

Whiteboard handwritten in blue marker: a sketch of the area under y = sinx from x = 0 to a with a differential strip dA = dx dy, followed by centroid formulas Xc and Yc and a double-integral derivation of Xc = a/2.

Hand-drawn whiteboard sketch of the area under y = sin x from x = 0 to x = a, hatched, with a small differential rectangle marked dx wide and dy tall, and x and y coordinate axes labeled.

Handwritten blue-marker derivation on a whiteboard finding the centroid x_c of a region under y = sin x, using double integrals over dA = dx dy and dividing by area A = a sin x.


His method for solving the double integrals is different from the method that I remeber and what my Cal book states as the proper way. Here is an example of how he is doing double integrals for the same problem, these are straight from my inclass notes:

Handwritten whiteboard derivation of a double integral for area: dA = dx dy, A = integral over A of dx dy, rewritten as a double integral with limits 0 to a and 0 to sin x, then reversed order to 0 to a for x and 0 to sin x for y, giving A = 1 - cos a.


If someone has some insight on which method is correct and what I should do differently to solve my moment of an area problem I would really appreciate some help.

Thanks, Jacob
 
Oh and the area/plate on the graph is homogeneous.