Double Integral Problem: Incorrect Jacobian Calculation for Polar Coordinates

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
Amaelle
Messages
318
Reaction score
55
Homework Statement
integral of int y^2 dxdy over a region (look to the formula inside the exercice)
Relevant Equations
y=rcos(theta)
calculate the double integral
Double integral of y squared with respect to x and y, written as the integral sign with the integrand y^2 dx dy.


over the region of integration is
x^2 + y^2 ≤ 4; x^2 + (y/4)^2 ≥ 1
the integrals have been made over two regions
Three coordinate-plane diagrams: left, a disk of radius 2 with a vertical elliptical hole shaded as region A; middle, the full disk of radius 2 shaded as A1; right, a vertically stretched ellipse reaching y = ±2 and x = ±1 shaded as A2.


my problem is that when I go to the polar coordinate for the ellipsis and use the jacobian i got 2 instead of 8 ( the following is the professor solution)
Integral expression: the integral over A2' = [0,1] x [0,2π] of 8ρ^3 sin^2 θ dρ dθ.


Any help?
many thanks in advance!
 
[tex]\int_{A_1}y^2 dx dy = \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^2 d\rho\ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta = 16 \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^1 d\rho \ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta[/tex]
A half of it,
[tex]\int_{A_2}y^2 dx dy = 8 \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^1 d\rho \ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta=\int_{A_1-A_2}y^2 dx dy[/tex]
What Jacobian you get ?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Amaelle
Amaelle said:
Homework Statement:: integral of int y^2 dxdy over a region (look to the formula inside the exercice)
Relevant Equations:: y=rcos(theta)

calculate the double integral
[tex] \int y^2\,dx\,dy[/tex]over the region of integration is
x^2 + y^2 ≤ 4; x^2 + (y/4)^2 ≥ 1
the integrals have been made over two regions

my problem is that when I go to the polar coordinate for the ellipsis and use the jacobian i got 2 instead of 8 ( the following is the professor solution)

Any help?
many thanks in advance!

For the ellipse, you need to use the parametrization [tex] \begin{align*} x &= \rho \cos \vartheta, \\ y &= 2\rho\sin \vartheta. \end{align*}[/tex] With this choice, the ellipse is at [itex]\rho = 1[/itex], rather than the complicated function of [itex]\vartheta[/itex] you would get from actual polar coordinates.

You should obtain a factor of 2 from the jacobian and a further two factors from the integrand.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Amaelle
Thanks a lot
so first change
u=x
v=y/2
so the jacobian equal 2
after
v=2rsin(theta)
v^2=4[sin(theta)]^2

I got it now
 
anuttarasammyak said:
[tex]\int_{A_1}y^2 dx dy = \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^2 d\rho\ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta = 16 \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^1 d\rho \ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta[/tex]
A half of it,
[tex]\int_{A_2}y^2 dx dy = 8 \int_0^{2\pi} d\theta \int_0^1 d\rho \ \rho^3 \sin^2\theta=\int_{A_1-A_2}y^2 dx dy[/tex]
What Jacobian you get ?
Thanks a lot!