• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Addition of Velocities Special Relativity Problem

  • #1
[Mentor's note: this post does not use the homework template because it was originally posted in a non-homework forum.]

-----------------------------

A ship (attached to reference frame S') is passing us (standing in reference frame S) with velocity v= 0.933c. A proton is fired at speed 0.959c relative to the ship from the front of the ship to the rear. The proper length of the ship is 756 m. What is the temporal separation between the time the proton is fired and the time it hits the rear wall of the ship according to (a) a passenger in the ship and (b) us? Suppose that, instead, the proton is fired from the rear to the front. What then is the temporal separation between the time it is fired and the time it hits the front wall according to (c) the passenger and (d) us?

Attempt at a solution:
a) v=0.933c
u'=-0.959c
=> gamma = 3.52851
=> L'=214.255m
By time = distance/speed, temporal separation is 0.745microseconds

b)
v=0.933c
u'=-0.959c
Using velocity addition formula => u=-0.247024c
=> gamma = 1.03198
=> L'=712.571m
By time = distance/speed, temporal separation is 9.89microseconds

c) Same as a?

d) v=0.933c
u'=+0.959c
Using velocity addition formula => u=0.9985c
=> gamma = 26.2631
=> L'=28.7856m
By time = distance/speed, temporal separation is 0.136microseconds

Would love some hints on where I am going wrong, these are all incorrect.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
20,217
4,258
With regard to part (a), suppose you decided to measure the speed of the proton. So you would fire the proton from the front of the ship x' = 0 at t' = 0, and you would have another guy at the back of the ship at x' = -756 m record the time t' = Δt' at which the proton arrives. You would then determine that the speed of the proton was 756/Δt' m/s. This is how you reckon velocity from the frame of reference of the ship. So, what is the value of Δt' that would be measured?

Chet
 
  • #3
Would length contraction not occur? Or do I simply need to multiply my time by gamma to account for time dilation?
Thank you for your response!
 
  • #4
20,217
4,258
Would length contraction not occur? Or do I simply need to multiply my time by gamma to account for time dilation?
Thank you for your response!
What I described in my previous post was how you would measure the velocity of the proton within the rocket if the only tools you had available were a meter stick and two synchronized clocks. Neither time dilation nor length contraction would have to be taken into consideration in this measurement. This is how the value of 0.959c would be determined experimentally, and this is what the speed of the proton would mean to the people residing inside the rocket.

Chet
 

Related Threads on Addition of Velocities Special Relativity Problem

Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
927
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
526
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
Top