Atomic Structure: Uncovering the Nucleon of Chlorine 35.5

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of chlorine's nucleon count being 35.5, which is not a whole number. This is attributed to the distinction between atomic mass and atomic weight. Atomic mass refers to the mass of a single atom, including its protons, neutrons, and electrons, while atomic weight is the average mass of all isotopes of an element, normalized to 1/12 of the mass of a carbon-12 atom. The conversation also touches on the specification of atomic mass being measured when an atom is motionless, noting that motion can affect mass due to relativistic effects. Additionally, atomic weight is described as a dimensionless quantity, meaning it has no associated units. The conclusion drawn is that the non-integer value of chlorine's nucleon count results from averaging the masses of its isotopes, which often leads to decimal values.
Jadaav
Messages
175
Reaction score
1
I got a question :

Why is the nucleon of Chlorine 35.5 ? Why is is not a whole number ?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
35.5 is not an atomic mass, it is atomic weight of the element.
 
What's the difference between atomic mass and atomic weight of an element ?
 
Have you ever heard about google and wikipedia?
 
Yeah, I searched in Wikipedia.
 
And you still don't know what is a difference between the two? Can you quote or write - in your own words - one line definitions of both?
 
Atomic mass is the mass of 1 atom comprising of its protons, neutrons and electrons.

Atomic weight is the average mass of all the atoms of an element that exist to 1/12 of the mass of an atom of Carbon - 12.

Am I right here ?

Wikipedia says this:

"The atomic mass is the total mass of protons, neutrons and electrons in a single atom (when the atom is motionless)"

Why does it specify when the atom is motionless ? Does it make a difference if its in motion ?

"Atomic weight (symbol: Ar) is a dimensionless physical quantity,..."

What is a dimensionless physical quantity ?
 
Last edited:
Jadaav said:
Am I right here ?

Yes.

Now, get back to your question and see if you can answer it.

Why does it specify when the atom is motionless ? Does it make a difference if its in motion?

Yes - moving objects get heavier (although for the effect to be observable their speed must be real high). Google for "relativistic mass".

What is a dimensionless physical quantity ?

One that has no units. Mass has units of kg (pound, stone...), length has units of m (feet, cable...), atomic weight has no units.
 
Now I got the answer to my question. It is not a whole number because it is the average mass of the element. When making averages, we often encounter decimals.
 
  • #10
Wasn't that hard :smile:
 
  • #11
Yeah, thanks to you:smile:
 
Back
Top