Braking force of a truck

  • Thread starter chrishgv
  • Start date
  • #1
14
1
Hi guys i'm a truck driver. Not sure if i'm posting in the right place so i apologise. Iv'e been on a course today about trucks. The course leader was talking about forces. A trucks force forwards can be 0.8. Is this true?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
14
1
Hi guys i'm a truck driver. Not sure if i'm posting in the right place so i apologise. Iv'e been on a course today about trucks. The course leader was talking about forces. A trucks force forwards can be 0.8. Is this true?
We were talking about carrying a load. We have to make sure the load is safe. The biggest force a hgv truck produces under breaking is 0.8 going forwards. does this seem correct?
 
  • #3
14
1
We were talking about carrying a load. We have to make sure the load is safe. The biggest force a hgv truck produces under breaking is 0.8 going forwards. does this seem correct?
This is probably correct . My real questioning is when he said that.. Because people get whiplash. There is a force pushing backwards when you break hard. He says a pallet on the truck will move backwards after a crash???
 
  • #4
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,676
7,251
A trucks force forwards can be 0.8. Is this true?
A truck’s force certainly could be 0.8 in some units. Are you familiar with the concept of units? Like distances can be measured in inches or miles or meters. Forces are usually measures in newtons or pounds (pounds can be confusing because it is sometimes a unit of force and sometimes a unit of mass and so context is needed)
 
  • Like
Likes chrishgv
  • #5
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
9,474
4,165
We were talking about carrying a load. We have to make sure the load is safe. The biggest force a hgv truck produces under breaking is 0.8 going forwards. does this seem correct?
For those of us in the U.S., a "HGV" truck is a Heavy Goods truck. Which is what we would call an "18 wheeler" or a "semi-trailer truck".

It is plausible that such a truck can brake at 0.8 gees of acceleration. This means that the carried goods can experience an apparent forward force equal to 0.8 times their weight.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2, russ_watters and chrishgv
  • #6
14
1
A truck’s force certainly could be 0.8 in some units. Are you familiar with the concept of units? Like distances can be measured in inches or miles or meters. Forces are usually measures in newtons or pounds (pounds can be confusing because it is sometimes a unit of force and sometimes a unit of mass and so context is needed)
Iv'e had a drink. Bare with me. On the course he says there is a force pushing backwards after a crash. He references whiplash. If a pallet off bricks was moving forward on the wagon during a crash. could a force push it backwards afterwards?
 
  • #7
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,676
7,251
Collisions are pretty complicated with lots of things happening very quickly. Whiplash is usually associated with a rear end collision with an inadequate or poorly positioned headrest.

I could envision that during a frontal collision a pallet of bricks could slide forward to the cabin and essentially act as a rear end collision just moments after the original frontal collision. I don’t know any studies on it, but it seems plausible to me.
 
  • Like
Likes chrishgv
  • #8
14
1
Ok. After a collision. He is saying a pallet off bricks (anything) will move backwards after a crash. I this possible?
 
  • #9
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,676
7,251
Ok. After a collision. He is saying a pallet off bricks (anything) will move backwards after a crash. I this possible?
For a frontal collision I can’t envision how it could happen. For a rear end collision certainly the can happen.
 
  • Like
Likes chrishgv
  • #10
14
1
ok thank you. He's stating his theory on the basis of whiplash. It just seemed against the laws of physics to me. He teaches this class to 20 people a week. Can i get any feedback to show how he is going wrong?
 
  • #11
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,676
7,251
Can i get any feedback to show how he is going wrong?
Can you explain the argument in detail?
 
  • #12
14
1
a lorry is traveling forward. a pallet of bricks is against the headboard of the trailer. the lorry crashes. after the crash the pallet of bricks moves backwards. he has an arrow on his chart showing the pallet moving backwards. he says for every action equal reaction. the pallet is moving backwards in his opinion.
 
  • #14
14
1
frontal crash. on his diagram after the crash the pallet has moved backwards in relation to the headboard of the truck.
 
  • #15
14
1
frontal crash. on his diagram after the crash the pallet has moved backwards in relation to the headboard of the truck.
he states there is a force pushing the pallet back? how is this possible? tx
 
  • #16
14
1
I just can't see a point where the pallet has gone backwards
 
  • #17
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,676
7,251
a lorry is traveling forward. a pallet of bricks is against the headboard of the trailer. the lorry crashes. after the crash the pallet of bricks moves backwards. he has an arrow on his chart showing the pallet moving backwards. he says for every action equal reaction. the pallet is moving backwards in his opinion.
When the truck crashes its acceleration is backwards (in the external inertial frame). So in the truck’s frame the inertial force is forwards. Relative to the truck the bricks will be accelerated forwards. There isn’t any rearward force on the bricks relative to the truck.
 
  • Like
Likes chrishgv
  • #18
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
9,474
4,165
When the truck crashes its acceleration is backwards (in the external inertial frame). So in the truck’s frame the inertial force is forwards. Relative to the truck the bricks will be accelerated forwards. There isn’t any rearward force on the bricks relative to the truck.
You could get some bounce, perhaps -- the truck bounces from the wall and the brick pallet bounces from the front wall of its compartment. One would have to speculate about what components are elastic enough to provide much bounce. An argument on a basis of "equal and opposite reaction" sounds like vigorous handwavium.
 
  • Like
Likes hmmm27, Dale and chrishgv
  • #19
14
1
handwavium wow. waves hands. The guy is a great teacher.
 
  • #20
14
1
When the truck crashes its acceleration is backwards (in the external inertial frame). So in the truck’s frame the inertial force is forwards. Relative to the truck the bricks will be accelerated forwards. There isn’t any rearward force on the bricks relative to the truck.
I'm assuming i was correct then? He's a good teacher. I'm here because i want to help him and his lessons. I'l give him this link tomorrow
 
  • Like
Likes Dale
  • #21
14
1
il sober up before i post again. don't worry i'm not driving i'm on a course this week. feel free to add more for clarification.
 
  • #22
14
1
just sobering up a bit and thinking about your answers. teacher mentions in his lesson that the head rest in a car is to stop whip lash. Am i right in thinking that you can only get whiplash from a rear end hit? I don't think he understands this. He thinks whip lash comes from the (recoil?)
 
  • #23
nasu
Gold Member
3,769
428
Ask him what is the point of wearing sit belts. If you are pushed backwards during frontal collision, I mean.
 
  • #24
jack action
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
2,043
2,583
teacher mentions in his lesson that the head rest in a car is to stop whip lash. Am i right in thinking that you can only get whiplash from a rear end hit?
From Wikipedia:
A WHIPS [Whiplash Protection System] equipped seat is designed so that the entire backrest helps to protect the front occupant's neck in a case of a rear impact.
 
  • #25
256bits
Gold Member
3,293
1,322
Am i right in thinking that you can only get whiplash from a rear end hit?
No.
More often, occurrences of whiplash are from a rear end, but half as many can be from frontal, and also from a side collision.
 

Related Threads on Braking force of a truck

  • Last Post
Replies
0
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
13K
  • Last Post
Replies
24
Views
10K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
30
Views
6K
Replies
15
Views
987
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
7K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Top