Calculate magnetic dipole of other planets relative to the Earth

  • #1
Kovac
13
2
Thread moved from the technical forums to the schoolwork forums
3.PNG


So I have a few questions regarding the above task.

I will use this equation to get the results for the different planets:
eq.PNG


Questions:

  1. So in the equation density p= mass of proton x proton density of the solar wind x 1000 000 (conversion between kgcm^-3 to kgm^-3) x 1/r^2 (I assume that I should multiply this equation in here since it says that the solar wind density is decreasing with distance). Question: Is this correctly assumed?
  2. B = M/r^3 where M= magnetic dipole of the planet in question, r= radius of the planet in question. For radius I have a table with values, but for M Im having trouble interpreting what to write since it says "relative to earth".
    table.PNG
Question: What does the M value become for Mercury? Should I take Eart value * Mercury relative value? Or Is it simply 3.8 x 10^-4 or should I take the delta between earth value and the value for Mercury in the table? Its because it says relative to earth what confuses me, if you google the value for mercury its a lot bigger than the table is showing.μ0= 4pi x 10^-7 Vs/Am [magnetic permiability of free space], stays the same (not planet dependent)
u= solar wind velocity (not planet dependent). Will assume a value.
 

Attachments

  • 3.PNG
    3.PNG
    9.5 KB · Views: 42
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Kovac said:
  1. So in the equation density p= mass of proton x proton density of the solar wind x 1000 000 (conversion between kgcm^-3 to kgm^-3) x 1/r^2 (I assume that I should multiply this equation in here since it says that the solar wind density is decreasing with distance). Question: Is this correctly assumed?
Yes, the factor of ##1/r^2## should be there. [EDIT: Actually, you should NOT have the explicit factor of ##1/r^2##if your proton density already includes the ##1/r^2## behavior. Answering the questions below should help clarify this.]

You are given that the proton number density at ##r = 1## AU is ##10## cm-3. So, how would you express the proton number density as a function of ##r## where ##r## is in AU?

How would you express the mass density ##\rho## of protons as a function of ##r## for ##r## in AU?

Kovac said:
Question: What does the M value become for Mercury? Should I take Eart value * Mercury relative value? Or Is it simply 3.8 x 10^-4 or should I take the delta between earth value and the value for Mercury in the table? Its because it says relative to earth what confuses me, if you google the value for mercury its a lot bigger than the table is showing.

For the earth you have the equation
1696096200153.png

Presumably, ##B_E## is some sort of value of the earth's magnetic field at the earth's surface. Hopefully, you have a value for this. For a different planet, you will need to replace ##B_E## by the planet's surface magnetic field, ##B_{planet}##. Try to express ##B_{planet}## in terms of ##B_E## , the radii of the earth and the planet, and the magnetic dipole moments of the earth and the planet. This should allow you to find ##B_{planet}## in terms of ##B_E## and values in your table.

EDIT #2: I just noticed that your table in post #1 gives a value for the earth's magnetic moment at the bottom of the table. So, you can use the table to find the numerical value of the magnetic moment of the planet. Then you can find the magnetic field at the surface of the planet from the magnetic moment and the radius of the planet. So, you will not need to worry about a numerical value for the earth's field ##B_E##.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Even though B is usually used for magnetic field (in Tesla) here it designates the magnetic moment. And if you have the relative radius on the left hand size it should be relative moment on the right hand size.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetopause
 
  • #4
nasu said:
Even though B is usually used for magnetic field (in Tesla) here it designates the magnetic moment. And if you have the relative radius on the left hand size it should be relative moment on the right hand size.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetopause
The link writes the magnetopause distance as $$r_{mp} \approx \sqrt[6]{\frac {2 B_0^2}{\mu_0 \rho v^2}}$$ where ##B_0## is the magnetic moment. (Not a great notation since the link also used ##B## for magnetic field.)

However, in this problem, the formula given is for the ratio of ##r_{mp}## to the earth's radius ##r_E##. So, using the formula from wikipedia, we have $$\frac{r_{mp}}{r_E} \approx \sqrt[6]{\frac {2 (B_0/r_E^3)^2}{\mu_0 \rho v^2}}$$ The quantity ##B_0/(r_E)^3## is the earth's magnetic field at the surface of the earth: ##B_E##. So, we get $$\frac{r_{mp}}{r_E} \approx \sqrt[6]{\frac {2 B_E^2}{\mu_0 \rho v^2}}$$ This agrees with the formula given in the first post except for numerical factors.
 
  • #5
Kovac said:
Question: What does the M value become for Mercury?
This table of planetary moments (relative to Earth's) and magnetopause distances (in terms of planetary radii), from the Wikipedia entry that @TSny cited, should help answer some of your questions and serve as a check on your calculations:
1696102287833.png
 
  • Like
Likes TSny

1. How is the magnetic dipole of other planets calculated?

The magnetic dipole of other planets is calculated by measuring the strength and direction of their magnetic fields. This can be done using specialized instruments such as magnetometers or by analyzing data from spacecraft flybys.

2. What is the magnetic dipole of Earth and how does it compare to other planets?

The magnetic dipole of Earth is approximately 25 microtesla and is tilted at an angle of about 11.5 degrees relative to the planet's rotational axis. This is relatively strong compared to other planets, with the exception of Jupiter, which has a much stronger magnetic field.

3. How does the magnetic dipole of other planets affect their atmospheres?

The magnetic dipole of other planets can play a significant role in shaping their atmospheres. For example, a strong magnetic field can protect a planet's atmosphere from being stripped away by solar wind, while a weaker field may lead to atmospheric erosion.

4. Can the magnetic dipole of other planets change over time?

Yes, the magnetic dipole of other planets can change over time due to a variety of factors such as changes in the planet's interior structure or external influences like solar activity. This can result in fluctuations in the strength and orientation of the magnetic field.

5. How is the magnetic dipole of other planets related to their potential for hosting life?

The magnetic dipole of a planet can have important implications for its potential to support life. A strong magnetic field can protect a planet's atmosphere and surface from harmful radiation, making it more hospitable for life. However, a weak or non-existent magnetic field may make a planet more vulnerable to these harmful effects.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
237
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
25
Views
285
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
356
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
577
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
904
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
300
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top