Calculate the protons kinetic energy

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating various properties of a proton with total energy E=3E0, specifically its kinetic energy, velocity, momentum, and mass. Participants clarify that the kinetic energy should be calculated as Ek=2E0, and the momentum as p=√8E0/c. There is confusion regarding the mass calculations, with distinctions made between rest mass and relativistic mass, leading to different results based on the energy definitions used. The formula for velocity is also debated, with v=pc^2/E being derived from momentum and mass relationships. Overall, the conversation highlights the complexities of relativistic physics and the importance of consistent definitions in calculations.
asdf1
Messages
734
Reaction score
0
for the following question:
a proton with the total energy E=3E0please calculat the proton's (a) kinetic energy (b) velocity (c) momentum (d)mass

my problem:
1) can someone double check my work?
(a)Ek=2EE0
(c) p=[8^(0.5)]EE0/c
(d) I've tried
(mc^2)^2 + Ek^2 +2m(c^2)Ek=(mc^2)^2+(pc)^2
=>9E0^2+(2E03E0)=8E0^2
which is weird...
the rest I'm not sure how to calculate?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
But the problem doesn't even state that the proton is moving. This is absurd.

What formula did you use for (a). I can't make sense of it. Also, you say Ek = 2EE0. But E = 3E0. So we would have Ek = 6E0², right?
 
The proton must be moving by the sheer fact that the energy is greater than the rest energy (and we are not accounting for any other type of energies).
remember that
K = (\gamma-1) m_0 c^2=\gamma m_0 c^2 - m_0 c^2
but m_0 c^2 is the rest energy and \gamma m_0 c^2 is total energy
K= 3E_0 - E_0 = 2E_0
for d) Rest energy is
E_0 = m_0 c^2
so solve for m_0
 
Last edited:
Oh, I didn't get that E0 denotes the rest energy...
 
asdf1 said:
(a)Ek=2EE0
(c) p=[8^(0.5)]EE0/c

Neither of the above answers is correct, as you can tell by checking the units. In (a) you have units of energy on the left, but units of energy^2 on the right. That's a good sign that you omitted a square root somewhere. In (b) if you write your answer as pc=\sqrt{8} E E_0 you can see that you have the same trouble because pc has units of energy.

For part (d) you're supposed to find the mass. Which mass? Rest mass or relativistic mass? Either way, it's trivial. Hint: rest mass is to rest energy as relativistic mass is to (total) energy.
 
so
(a)2Eo
(c)p=[(8)^0.5]Eo/c
(d) p^2/2m=[(8)^0.5]Eo/c => m=2Eo/c^2 but why doesn't this equal the rest mass m=E0/c^2?
 
total energy E=3E0

calculate the proton's (a) kinetic energy (b) velocity (c) momentum (d)mass

Backwards seems easiest. Assuming E0 is rest energy, then:

(d) If by mass, rest mass is meant, then m0 = E0/c^2.
If relativistic mass is meant, then m = 3E0/c^2.

(c) pc = ROOT(E^2 - m0^2c^4)
So p = ROOT(9E0^2/c^2 - E0^2/c^2)
= ROOT(8)E0/c

(b) v = pc^2/E
= ROOT(8)/3 x c
= 0.94c

(a) Ekin = E - E0 = 2E0
 
Last edited:
why is the way that i calculated (d) incorrect?
also, where does "v = pc^2/E" come from in (b)?
 
asdf1 said:
so
(a)2Eo
(c)p=[(8)^0.5]Eo/c
(d) p^2/2m=[(8)^0.5]Eo/c => m=2Eo/c^2 but why doesn't this equal the rest mass m=E0/c^2?

p^2/2m is the non-relativistic kinetic energy, so your starting point for (d) says that the non-relativistic kinetic energy equals the relativistic momentum. How did you come up with that? :eek:
 
  • #10
asdf1 said:
why is the way that i calculated (d) incorrect?
Couldn't follow your logic, so I don't know, but this might help:

If relativistic mass is required:

m = p/v
= (ROOT(8)E0/c) / (ROOT(8)/3 x c)
= 3E0/c^2

If rest mass is required, then:

p = m0v/ROOT(1 - v^2/c^2), so...
m^2 = p^2/v^2 * (1 - v^2/c^2)
= (8E0^2/c^2)/(8c^2/9)*(1 - (8c^2/9)/c^2)
= (9E0^2/c^4)*(1/9)
= E0^2/c^4, so...
m = E0/c^2

asdf1 said:
also, where does "v = pc^2/E" come from in (b)?
v = pc^2/E comes from:

p = mv, so...
v = p/m

m = E/c^2, so...
v = pc^2/m
 
  • #11
thank you very much! :)
 

Similar threads

Replies
30
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
24
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
11K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
5K
Back
Top