Can High School Students Build a Spring-Assisted Magnetic Motor?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HeJind
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    even Project
AI Thread Summary
High school students in a summer engineering program are tasked with creating a spring-assisted magnetic motor, but they struggle to understand the concept due to language barriers with their professor. The design appears to involve magnets and gears, but participants express skepticism about its feasibility, noting that over-unity devices contradict thermodynamic laws. Forum responses emphasize that perpetual motion machines (PMMs) are not viable and suggest the assignment may be a misguided attempt to illustrate this principle. The discussion concludes with a warning against pursuing such projects, as they are considered non-existent. Overall, the project raises concerns about its educational value and practicality.
HeJind
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
So just some background info...I'm in a summer engineering program. We're all high school students (with little to no engineering experience), and we've only been in the program for two weeks now.

Just recently our professor assigned my group an assignment to create a spring-assisted magnetic motor. He drew a diagram for us on how to build it, but I simply don't understand how it works. To make it worse, our professor is from another country and speaks imperfect English with a strong accent. Needless to say, he's not the best at explaining things.

So the diagram is as follows:

mr5a1.jpg


From what I understand, the topmost magnets exert force on each other, which then sends a force down the middle pole. This somehow turns the gears at the bottom, which turn each other. The gears then force the left & right poles upward, which does something to the magnets, which keeps them turning. There are also springs on the left & right to control the speed of the left & right rods?

Is this even possible, let alone for high school kids? From what I gathered on the internet, over-unity designs have never worked and go against the laws of thermodynamics.

Can someone explain this to me? Thanks.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Is it possible that your prof gave you a perpetual motion project to teach you that it would never work?
 
Agreed. It looks like a very poor attempt at an over-unity device. Don't waste your time on it. (Are you sure that this guy is an exchange teacher, rather than some escaped lunatic with false ID?)
 
Welcome to the PF.

We do not discuss PMMs or over-unity devices at the PF. They do not exist. Thread is closed.
 
Hi all, I have a question. So from the derivation of the Isentropic process relationship PV^gamma = constant, there is a step dW = PdV, which can only be said for quasi-equilibrium (or reversible) processes. As such I believe PV^gamma = constant (and the family of equations) should not be applicable to just adiabatic processes? Ie, it should be applicable only for adiabatic + reversible = isentropic processes? However, I've seen couple of online notes/books, and...
Thread 'How can I find the cleanout for my building drain?'
I am a long distance truck driver, but I recently completed a plumbing program with Stratford Career Institute. In the chapter of my textbook Repairing DWV Systems, the author says that if there is a clog in the building drain, one can clear out the clog by using a snake augur or maybe some other type of tool into the cleanout for the building drain. The author said that the cleanout for the building drain is usually near the stack. I live in a duplex townhouse. Just out of curiosity, I...
I have an engine that uses a dry sump oiling system. The oil collection pan has three AN fittings to use for scavenging. Two of the fittings are approximately on the same level, the third is about 1/2 to 3/4 inch higher than the other two. The system ran for years with no problem using a three stage pump (one pressure and two scavenge stages). The two scavenge stages were connected at times to any two of the three AN fittings on the tank. Recently I tried an upgrade to a four stage pump...
Back
Top