Capacitance of 3 Hollow Cylinders

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the capacitance of three concentric hollow cylinders with specified radii and charge distributions. The charge distribution is determined by the surface areas of the cylinders, leading to charges of λ/4 on the inner cylinder and 3λ/4 on the outer cylinder. To find capacitance, the electric field must be integrated to determine potential differences, with the integration limits being from R to 2R and 2R to 3R. The user contemplates whether to treat the system as two capacitors in series or parallel due to the wire connection between the outer cylinders. Clarification on the configuration and charge distribution is essential for accurately calculating the total capacitance of the system.
adenine7
Messages
10
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I'm trying to find the capacitance of a system of 3 concentric hollow cylinders. The first cylinder has radius R, the second radius 2R, the third radius 3R. Cylinders 1 and 3 are connected by a wire. In total, they have charge +λ, and the second cylinder has charge -λ. The cylinders are infinitely long.

Homework Equations


Ehollow cylinder = (1 / 2πεo)*(Q / RL)
C= Q / V

The Attempt at a Solution


Since cylinders 1 and 3 are connected by the wire, the charge will distribute evenly according to surface area. Cylinder 3 has 3 times as much surface area, so it will have charge 3λ/4 (And Cylinder 1 will have charge λ/4).

I know that to solve this problem I must integrate the electric field to find the potential, and use that in C=Q/V to find capacitance. However, I don't really understand what the limits of my integration are. The outer cylinders are positive, so their electric fields point inwards to the middle cylinder. Do I account for their opposite directions (cancelling each other out partially)? Do I just integrate E from R to 3R? Do I need to multiply two oppositely signed integrals by the proportion of charge?

I was thinking of multiplying ∫E from R to 2R by λ/4, and multiplying ∫E from 2R to 3R by 3λ/4, then subtracting those. My believe my biggest trouble is that I don't understand how to deal with more than 2 surfaces for capacitor (and I can't find anything to help me online).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you tried treating the setup as two capacitors?
 
Thanks for the reply!
Ok, so treating it as two capacitors (Where V1 is potential difference for the inner two cylinders and V3 is potential difference for the outer two cylinders):

V1 = -∫R2R Q / 8πεLR dR = -Qln(2) / 8πεL = Qln(1/2) / 8πεL

C= Q / V, so C1 = 8πεL / ln(1/2)

Same thing for C3, except Q is multiplied by 3/4 instead of 1/4.
C3 = 8πεL / 3ln(1/2)

Do I add these together to get the cumulative capacitance of the system?
 
Last edited:
Anyone know how I should proceed?
 
Are the caps connected in series or parallel?
 
I'm not sure I understand the question. The capacitor is 3 concentric cylinders, and the only wire in the problem is connecting the inner and outer cylinders (I guess this means they are connected in series?).
 
You are modelling a single complicated capacitor as an electrically equivalent network of simpler ideal capacitors connected by ideal "wires".
In this case you have two ideal caps - and there are two "wire" connections. (The ideal wires do not have to be physical wires - they can be any conductor that plays the role of equalizing the voltage between two places.)

If you sketch out the series and parallel configurations for two ideal caps, and look at how the charges are distributed between the plates, you should be able to figure out the configuration that is right for you.
 
Back
Top