Constructing accurate diagrams of word problem- Trig

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on accurately constructing diagrams for a word problem involving a canoe spotted at two distances, with a 40° angle between sightings. Participants evaluate two different drawings, determining that the first diagram is more appropriate as it aligns with the problem's straightforward interpretation, without involving angles of elevation or depression. The second drawing inaccurately suggests a perspective that includes an angle of depression. Guidance emphasizes the importance of practice in diagram construction to enhance understanding and problem-solving skills. Overall, clarity in diagram representation is crucial for accurately solving the problem.
opus
Gold Member
Messages
717
Reaction score
131

Homework Statement


A canoe is floating down a creek. The canoe is first spotted 80 feet away. 7 minutes later the canoe is 45 feet away, making a 40° angle between the two sightings.
How far did the canoe travel?

Homework Equations


Law of Sines and Law of Cosines

The Attempt at a Solution



This question is more in terms of constructing a proper diagram. I have two different drawings, and I'm really just looking for guidance as to which drawing is accurate to the given problem, and why the other isn't. They both seem to represent the problem, but they both don't seem to be saying the same thing.
Please see my attached image. Thank you!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Attached image
 

Attachments

  • C55E476A-FFEE-42EA-8F33-AE33221721EB.jpeg
    C55E476A-FFEE-42EA-8F33-AE33221721EB.jpeg
    12.6 KB · Views: 588
opus said:

Homework Statement


A canoe is floating down a creek. The canoe is first spotted 80 feet away. 7 minutes later the canoe is 45 feet away, making a 40° angle between the two sightings.
How far did the canoe travel?

Homework Equations


Law of Sines and Law of Cosines

The Attempt at a Solution



This question is more in terms of constructing a proper diagram. I have two different drawings, and I'm really just looking for guidance as to which drawing is accurate to the given problem, and why the other isn't. They both seem to represent the problem, but they both don't seem to be saying the same thing.
Please see my attached image. Thank you!
I think your first drawing is more appropriate. The second drawing seems to imply that the observer is on a high bank looking down at the canoe.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
Mention any details about angle of elevation or depression? None? All done in the same plane. Your upper diagram fits.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
Ok thanks guys. Once I get a drawing going, I can go from there. Making the actual drawing seems to be where the ambiguity is.
 
opus said:
Ok thanks guys. Once I get a drawing going, I can go from there. Making the actual drawing seems to be where the ambiguity is.
The description is not really ambiguous. The straightforward interpretation leads to the single triangle shown in the first picture. No mention of angles of elevation nor depression were given. Check again post #3.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
I guess I just need to do more of them. So the second drawing would relate to angle of depression I see.
 
opus said:
I guess I just need to do more of them. So the second drawing would relate to angle of depression I see.
BINGO! Right on target! Do MORE exercises; not fewer. Keep up practicing the many exercises, and from different books, for the same topics as you study and with experience you may become familiar with some types of exercises and they become easier to analyze and solve.
 
  • Like
Likes opus
Thanks guys.
 
Back
Top