Did I do this question correctly?

  • Thread starter Thread starter andgabbana
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating various aspects of a frictionless roller coaster system, including total energy, speed at different points, stopping force, and work done. The initial calculations for total energy and speed were mostly correct, but there were misunderstandings regarding the stopping force and work required to bring the car to a stop. The correct approach for calculating the stopping force involves using the total energy of the system divided by the stopping distance. The participants clarified that the work needed to stop the roller coaster is indeed equal to the total energy of the system, and the final calculations for stopping force and work were confirmed as correct. Overall, the importance of accounting for potential energy in the calculations was emphasized.
andgabbana
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Consider the frictionless roller coaster shown:
http://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm286/lanvin12/physics-2.jpg

If a 12 000-kg car starts at rest from Point A, calculate

a) the total energy of the system

b) the speed of the car at point B

c) the force that must be applied to bring it to a stop at point E

d) the work done to bring it to a stop at point EHere's what I did...

a)
E(T) = E(K) + E(P)
= 1/2(mv^2) + mgh
=1/2(12000 x 0) + (12000 x 9.8 x 95)
=1.1x10^7 J

b)
E(T1) = E(T2)
1/2(V1^2) + gh(1) = 1/2(v2^2) + gh(2)
9.8 x 95 = 1/2(v2^2) + (9.8 x 65)
931 = 1/2(v2^2) + 637
V(2) = 24m/s

c)
1/2(V1^2) + gh(1) = 1/2(v2^2) + gh(2)
9.8 x 95 = 1/2(v2^2) + (9.8 x 25)
V(2) = 37.04m/s

F = mass ([Vf^2 - Vi^2] / [2 x delta d])
= 12000 ([0^2 - 37.04^2] / [2 x 7])
=-3.2x10^4 J

d)
W=E(K)
=1.1x10^7 J

Do you see any mistakes?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF.

Mostly good.

c) however must have a stopping force that absorbs all the potential energy, as in d) which you figured correctly.
 
LowlyPion said:
Welcome to PF.

Mostly good.

c) however must have a stopping force that absorbs all the potential energy, as in d) which you figured correctly.

Thanks.

I don't think I understand...? I just used the formula F = ma for c). Do I change my answer to a positive? And I'm not sure how to fix d)...
 
andgabbana said:
Thanks.

I don't think I understand...? I just used the formula F = ma for c). Do I change my answer to a positive? And I'm not sure how to fix d)...

Not quite.

9.8 x 95 = 1/2(v2^2) + (9.8 x 25)

That's incorrect. That gives the KE at the top of the last hill. It's the whole 95 m of PE that needs stopping
 
LowlyPion said:
Not quite.



That's incorrect. That gives the KE at the top of the last hill. It's the whole 95 m of PE that needs stopping

c)
I think I need to change my approach?
F = W/d
=(1.1x10^7 J) / 7m
=1.6x10^6 J

d)
W=E(P)
=1.1x10^7 J
...I thought the work required to stop the roller coaster is equal to the total energy of the system?
 
andgabbana said:
c)
I think I need to change my approach?
F = W/d
=(1.1x10^7 J) / 7m
=1.6x10^6 J

d)
W=E(P)
=1.1x10^7 J
...I thought the work required to stop the roller coaster is equal to the total energy of the system?


It is.

But you could have done it the first way too by taking all the potential as kinetic energy and figuring deceleration.

But not J for force.
 
LowlyPion said:
It is.

But you could have done it the first way too by taking all the potential as kinetic energy and figuring deceleration.

But not J for force.

oops... my mistake!
c)
F = W/d
=(1.1x10^7 J) / 7m
=1.6x10^6 N
 
LowlyPion said:
It is.

But you could have done it the first way too by taking all the potential as kinetic energy and figuring deceleration.

But not J for force.

Just to confirm, did I finally do c) and d) correctly?
 
andgabbana said:
Just to confirm, did I finally do c) and d) correctly?

Looks OK. Total energy from potential needs to be accounted for after all.
 
  • #10
LowlyPion said:
Looks OK. Total energy from potential needs to be accounted for after all.

Thank you!
 
Back
Top