How should I calculate the distance D with two different motions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter simphys
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the distance D in a scenario involving a boat and projectile motion. The original poster initially subtracted the boat's displacement from the projectile's range but was confused by a solution suggesting addition. Clarification revealed that the distance D should be measured from the moment the projectile is thrown, not at the end of its flight. Proper handling of signs in calculations is emphasized as crucial for resolving the issue. The conversation highlights the importance of clear communication and accurate timing in physics problems.
simphys
Messages
327
Reaction score
46
Homework Statement
An important piece of landing equipment must be thrown to
a ship, which is moving at 45.0 cm>s, before the ship can dock. This
equipment is thrown at 15.0 m>s at 60.0° above the horizontal from the
top of a tower at the edge of the water, 8.75 m above the ship’s deck
(Fig. P3.54). For this equipment to land at the front of the ship, at what
distance D from the dock should the ship be when the equipment is
thrown? Ignore air resistance
Relevant Equations
kinematic equations
pic.png


My question is this:
So in my solution, to get D I *substracted* the displacement of the boat within the same time interfval of the projectile motion from the range of the projectile motion. whilst in the solutions it says that I need to *add* them together.
Question: Why do I need to add them as the boat is going in the opposition direction, and from my reasoning I would think that the distance D would become smaller this way.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    60.6 KB · Views: 219
Physics news on Phys.org
edit: forgot the solution
 
simphys said:
So in my solution
I don't see no solution ?
Please post your work...

Anyway, if you deal with the signs properly, this shouldn't be a problem...

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
I don't see no solution ?
Please post your work...

Anyway, if you deal with the signs properly, this shouldn't be a problem...

##\ ##
I have ?
 
Oh gosh my apologies... wow I just find out at that it is says the distance D from the time when the equipment is thrown... mine was at the end of the thrown then..

My apologies for posting!
 
simphys said:
I have ?
Yes, after I posted :biggrin:

[edit] can hardly decipher it anyway ...
 
BvU said:
Yes, after I posted :biggrin:

[edit] can hardly decipher it anyway ...
Yeah my apologies :) I needed to quickly switch to the phone to post the pic afterwards. But for some reason it always pixelates my picture lol, they look crisp and clear when I look at it on the camera roll, strangeee
 
Miraculous camera if it can clarify those scribbles o0)
 
Back
Top