Do we all belong to the same star?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether all materials on Earth, including humans, originate from the same star. It argues that the likelihood of all necessary elements for complex life coming from a single star is slim, as the solar system formed from a nebula containing materials from multiple stars. The sun is identified as a third-generation star, incorporating elements from at least two previous stars, which is supported by the mixture of elements found within the sun and the solar system. The age of the universe and the lifecycle of stars further suggest that the solar system is composed of remnants from various stellar sources. This indicates a complex interstellar origin for the materials that make up life on Earth.
Yashbhatt
Messages
348
Reaction score
13
I recently read this kind of question on Quora and found it interesting. Do all of the Earth's materials(and therefore humans) belong the same star of different star? What's more likely?

In my opinion, the chances of all of the material belonging to one star are pretty slim because a complex organism like humans require a lot of of different elements and it is unlikely that a single star will contain all of his elements.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
The solar system formed from a nebula that would have most likely contained material originating from several previous stars.
That and quite a lot of interstellar hydrogen which never was previously in a star.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes |Glitch|
The sun is believed to be a 3rd generation star.
 
russ_watters said:
The sun is believed to be a 3rd generation star.
So?
 
Yashbhatt said:
So?
So it contains materials from at least 2 other stars.
 
russ_watters said:
So it contains materials from at least 2 other stars.

And what evidence do we have for it?
 
Yashbhatt said:
And what evidence do we have for it?
The mixture of elements in the sun and solar system. A first generation star doesn't have any heavier elements, so can't have any rocky planets around it.

See: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun
Under the sub-header "characteristics."
 
The universe was over 9 billion years old by the time the sun formed, and our galaxy was around 8 billion years old at that time. The lifespan of stars massive enough to produce heavy elements is measured in a handful of millions of years. This makes it a virtual certainty the solar system contains remnants of many stars.
 
Back
Top