Does wire length difference create phase shift?

AI Thread Summary
In wiring a 240 volt AC circuit, the assumption that L1 and L2 wires must be the same length to avoid phase shifts is largely unfounded, as significant phase shifts only occur with wire length differences of kilometers. Electricity travels at about one-third the speed of light, meaning that a 1-degree phase shift requires a difference of approximately 5 kilometers in wire length. Concerns about phase shifts are more relevant at higher frequencies, not typical household wiring frequencies like 50/60Hz. Proper installation practices, such as keeping wires twisted in a cable and ensuring they share the same path, help mitigate any potential issues. Overall, while it's good to be cautious, the magnitude of concern regarding wire length differences in this context is minimal.
yahastu
Messages
79
Reaction score
7
When wiring a 240 volt AC circuit, I've always assumed that it's important for L1 and L2 wires to be the exact same length, in order to avoid introducing a phase shift that would reduce peak voltage. Length differences can accumulate when the wires enter a panel and need to go slightly different places. However I can't find any information about this when I search. Is this true, or am i just being paranoid? is there any standards/ rules about this?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The short answer is that your sort of paranoid. The concept is absolutely correct, but you're way off in magnitude. If we assume that electricity travels at about 1/3 the speed of light in wires (a crude, but not unreasonable guess). Then the wavelength at 60Hz is roughly 2 million meters. So you can make a 1o phase shift if your wire lengths differ by about 5km.

That's why you can't find any info about it. No one worries about this at 50/60Hz. Engineers worry a lot about this stuff at very high frequencies.
 
  • Like
Likes anorlunda, yahastu and artis
@yahastu Basically what @DaveE said.
This would only be a problem if your house wiring worked on the mid Mhz and upwards frequency range, but then we wouldn't call it "house wiring" but "antenna looking like a house"

PS. I hope you took that advice we gave you in the other thread seriously before proceeding as I suppose you are with your "off grid" installation?
 
DaveE said:
The short answer is that your sort of paranoid. The concept is absolutely correct, but you're way off in magnitude. If we assume that electricity travels at about 1/3 the speed of light in wires (a crude, but not unreasonable guess). Then the wavelength at 60Hz is roughly 2 million meters. So you can make a 1o phase shift if your wire lengths differ by about 5km.

That's why you can't find any info about it. No one worries about this at 50/60Hz. Engineers worry a lot about this stuff at very high frequencies.
Awesome, thanks for explaining that. Makes sense!
artis said:
@yahastu Basically what @DaveE said.
This would only be a problem if your house wiring worked on the mid Mhz and upwards frequency range, but then we wouldn't call it "house wiring" but "antenna looking like a house"

PS. I hope you took that advice we gave you in the other thread seriously before proceeding as I suppose you are with your "off grid" installation?

The replies i received there did not seem to address to the questions i asked. However, after doing additional research, and consulting with another electrician, i feel fairly confident that i have found the answers to my questions.
 
yahastu said:
The replies i received there did not seem to address to the questions i asked.
They did, I for one explained why certain ideas you had were dangerous.
Anyway be careful, since it's your house you will suffer from any mistakes made.
 
yahastu said:
Length differences can accumulate when the wires enter a panel and need to go slightly different places. However I can't find any information about this when I search. Is this true, or am i just being paranoid? is there any standards/ rules about this?
You are fixating and overthinking some things, while not realising others.

Wires are often twisted in a cable, so that all conductors will have approximately the same length when the cable passes around a corner of the minimum design radius. The twist puts equal physical tension on all wires in the bundle, but it also keeps the accumulating electrical phase difference the same between conductors.

Once you separate the individual conductors from the bundle, it becomes critically important that the wires of one circuit share the same path through a metal frame, and always pass together through only one hole in a metal bulkhead. The external magnetic fields of the two or three circuit conductors can only cancel if the wires follow the same magnetic path. If the circuit wires were to pass through separate holes in a steel bulkhead, the magnetic field in the material between the holes would be multiple times that of a single conductor.
 
  • Like
Likes Averagesupernova
Thread 'Weird near-field phenomenon I get in my EM simulation'
I recently made a basic simulation of wire antennas and I am not sure if the near field in my simulation is modeled correctly. One of the things that worry me is the fact that sometimes I see in my simulation "movements" in the near field that seems to be faster than the speed of wave propagation I defined (the speed of light in the simulation). Specifically I see "nodes" of low amplitude in the E field that are quickly "emitted" from the antenna and then slow down as they approach the far...
Hello dear reader, a brief introduction: Some 4 years ago someone started developing health related issues, apparently due to exposure to RF & ELF related frequencies and/or fields (Magnetic). This is currently becoming known as EHS. (Electromagnetic hypersensitivity is a claimed sensitivity to electromagnetic fields, to which adverse symptoms are attributed.) She experiences a deep burning sensation throughout her entire body, leaving her in pain and exhausted after a pulse has occurred...
Back
Top