Electric field inside a cavity in a dielectric

6 replies · 8K views · last reply
Pushoam
Messages
961
Reaction score
53
Textbook figure 4.18 and 4.19: a dielectric with a spherical cavity labelled a and b and polarization P arrows, beside separate sphere, needle and wafer cavity shapes, with P pointing upward.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



A)[/B] In the spherical cavity, let me have a Gaussian Spherical Surface around the center.
Applying Gauss' s Law for dielectrics,
##\oint _S\vec D⋅ d \vec a = Q_{f_{en}} ##
Due to the symmetry of the problem and ## Q_{f_{en}} =0## , ## \vec D = 0 ##.
Since, ## \vec P = 0 ##, ##\vec E ## inside the cavity, too, is zero.
Is this correct?
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page titled 4.2.3 The Field Inside a Dielectric, discussing the difference between pure and physical dipoles and the macroscopic field as an average over many atoms, with a footnote on averaging.
    upload_2017-8-8_18-47-24.png
    81.6 KB · Views: 897
  • Textbook page showing Figure 4.16, a dielectric sphere with a small spherical cavity of radius r, followed by text and numbered equations 4.17 to 4.19 on the macroscopic field in a polarized dielectric.
    upload_2017-8-8_18-50-51.png
    25.6 KB · Views: 977
  • Textbook page showing Figure 4.16, a sphere of radius R with a small point r inside, followed by equations 4.17 to 4.19 on electric field averaging in a polarized dielectric sphere.
    upload_2017-8-8_18-52-19.png
    28 KB · Views: 960
## D ## is the quantity that stays uniform everywhere. ## \nabla \cdot D=0 ## since there are no free electrical charges. In general, ## D=\epsilon_o E+P ##. But ## P=0 ## inside the cavity. This allows you to get an answer for ## E ## inside the cavity in terms of ## D ##. ## \\ ## One additional question you might have is what is ## P ## in the material? That depends upon the polarizability ## \alpha ## of the material. In general ## P= \alpha E_o ##, but they don't tell you what ## \alpha ## is for the material. They simply tell you that ## P ## has some known value. ## \\ ## And one additional input: I believe the assumption that ## D ## is perfectly uniform is an approximation. For the case of a dielectric sphere in a uniform electric field, that approximation is exact. When the material is uniform, except for a (spherical) cavity, I believe just outside the spherical cavity, the electric field is not perfectly uniform for the exact solution to this problem, but the assumption is made, (and it is accurate to a very good approximation), that the electric field is indeed uniform throughout the material, including the region just outside the cavity.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Pushoam
Pushoam said:
Due to the symmetry of the problem and ## Q_{f_{en}} =0 , ⃗D=0
A) There is something wrong in this argument. I can't assume symmetry as I don't know the nature of ##\vec E_0##.

Considering the cavity as the superposition of original dielectric material and a sphere of polarization - ## \vec P ##.
Electric field due to this sphere inside the cajvity is ## \vec E _{sp} = \vec P/3ε_0 ##
The electric field inside the cavity is ## \vec E_{ca} = \vec E_0 + \{\vec E _{sp} = \vec P/3ε_0\}##
## \vec D = ε_0 \vec E_0 + 0 ## ##= ε_0 \vec E_0 + \vec P - 2 \vec P /3 ##
## = \vec D_0 - \frac 2 3 \vec P
##

B) Considering the cavity as the superposition of original dielectric material and a needle of polarization - ## \vec P ##.
There will be surface charge density only on the two ends of the needle. Assuming that the total charge is so small that the electric field due to it is negligible compared to ##\vec E_0##.
So,
## \vec E_{ca} = \vec E_0 ##
## \vec D = \vec D_0 - \vec P##

C) Considering the cavity as the superposition of original dielectric material and a wafer of polarization - ## \vec P ##.

Diagram of a thin wafer-shaped cavity between two red ellipses representing capacitor plates, with plus signs marking positive charge on the upper surface and a dashed line below. A large yellow arrow labelled "Electric field due to capacitor" points down, and a red arrow labelled "Polarization of wafer P'=-P" points down beside it.

The positive surface charge density is on the upper surface and the negative charge density is on the lower plate.
So, electric field due to this wafer ## \vec E_{wa} = \frac {-\vec P} {ε_0}
\\ \vec E = \vec E_0 + \frac {-\vec P} {ε_0} ##
## \vec D = \vec D_0 - 2 \vec P##

Is this correct so far?

The solution means that depending on the shape of the cavity, the electric field and the displacement are different inside cavities in a large dielectric with uniform polarization, electric field, displacement.
 
The charge distribution in the above figure is wrong. Actually I thought the wafer as a || plate capacitor and the external electric field due to which the polarization occurs is in the direction of polarization of wafer. Because of this, the positive charge of the upper plate goes to the lower surface of the upper plate and the negative charge of the lower plate goes to the upper surface of the lower plate.

But, this is wrong. What happens is : Due to the external electric field, there devlops Polarization in the dielectrics.
Now, the surface charge density on the upper and the lower surface is given by: ##σ_{up} = \vec P' ⋅ \hat z = - P \\ σ_{down} = \vec P' . \left(- \hat z \right ) =P##
Diagram of a dielectric wafer between capacitor plates: yellow plus signs mark positive charge on the bottom plate and dashed lines mark the top plate; a red arrow labelled Electric field due to capacitor points up, and a red arrow labelled Polarization of wafer P'=-P points down.


So, electric field due to this wafer
##\vec E_{wa} = \frac {\vec P} {ε_0} \\ \vec E = \vec E_0 + \frac {\vec P} {ε_0}

\\ \vec D = \vec D_0 ##

Is this correct so far?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Charles Link
Correct on three counts. Well done.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Pushoam and Charles Link
Yes, @Pushoam very good. My original suggestion, that ## \vec{D} ## is continuous (and uniform) only works for case C. You correctly superimposed a material of polarization "-P" for the other two cases.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Pushoam
Charles Link said:
Yes, @Pushoam very good. My original suggestion, that ## \vec{D} ## is continuous (and uniform) only works for case C. You correctly superimposed a material of polarization "-P" for the other two cases.
One additional comment=I am somewhat puzzled by the solution of the superposition of the P's because essentially it implies that ## \vec{P} ## remains constant around the cavity. Meanwhile, if you were to compute the electric field outside the cavity caused by the polarization of "-P" and its surface polarization charge ## \sigma_p=\vec{P} \cdot \hat{n} ##, it is not uniform, so that it would cause the assumed uniform ## \vec{P} ## in the material just outside the cavity to change. In any case, you solved it correctly, but it appears the assumption/approximation is made that ## \vec{P} ## remains uniform.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Pushoam