Electric Flux Through a 1x1x1 cm Box

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the net electric flux through a 1x1x1 cm box in a specified electric field, E = (350x + 150)i N/C. The initial calculation incorrectly assumes uniform flux across the box's surfaces and neglects the contribution from the constant term (150). Participants clarify that the electric field varies with x, meaning the flux through the front and back faces must be calculated separately rather than simply multiplied by two. The correct approach involves evaluating the electric field at both x = 0 and x = 0.01 to determine the net flux accurately. Understanding the role of the constant term is crucial for arriving at the correct answer of 3.5x10^-4 Nm^2/C.
absolutezer0es
Messages
14
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A 1x1x1 cm box with edges aligned in the xyz-axes is in the electric field E = (350x + 150)i N/C, where x is in meters. What is the net electric flux through the box?

Homework Equations



flux = ExAx + EyAy + EzAz

The Attempt at a Solution



I substituted into the formula above, including 0.01m for x. I get:

flux = [(350*0.01 + 150)(0.01)^2] + 0 + 0 = 0.01535 Nm^2/C

I then multiply by two because the field is coming through the back and front of the box. I'm not getting the answer right though. What am I missing?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
absolutezer0es said:
I then multiply by two because the field is coming through the back and front of the box.
You cannot just multiply by 2. Calculate the flux through the front and back sides. (They aren't the same.) Then add to get the net flux, being careful with signs.
 
Why aren't they the same? Isn't it a cube? Maybe I don't understand the expression (350x + 150)i like I think I do.

Does the expression mean 350x on the way in and 150 on the way out?
 
absolutezer0es said:
Maybe I don't understand the expression (350x + 150)i like I think I do.
What's the field at x = 0? (Where one side is.) At x = 0.01? (Where the other side is.)
 
I'm still lost. The field at x=0? There are an infinite number of points on x=0, depending on y and z, no? Same at x=0.01.

I mean, the answer is 3.5x10^-4, according to my text. I substituted 0.01m into the expression and multiplied by (0.01)^2. Don't have a clue why though. What happened to the 150?
 
absolutezer0es said:
The field at x=0? There are an infinite number of points on x=0, depending on y and z, no? Same at x=0.01.
The field only depends on x. So all points with the same x value have the same field.
 
So what does the 150 mean? Does it have anything to do with the problem?
 
absolutezer0es said:
So what does the 150 mean? Does it have anything to do with the problem?
Of course it does! 350x + 150 is a function that gives you the magnitude of the electric field at any point. You can't leave out the 150.
 
Back
Top