Electric Force Textbook error?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a potential error in a textbook regarding the calculation of electric force using the formula FE = εq. The user calculated FE as 0.672 N, while the textbook provided an incorrect answer of 6.7*10^4 N. The user expresses frustration over the inaccuracies in the textbook, which is used for learning the course material. It is confirmed that the user's calculation is correct, and the text is indeed in error. The conversation highlights concerns about relying on flawed educational resources.
quicksilver123
Messages
173
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Find the net force given a point charge and the value of the electric field.



Homework Equations



FE = εq

ε= (5.6*10^4)
q=(-1.2 * 10^-5)

The Attempt at a Solution



FE = εq
FE = (5.6*10^4)(-1.2 * 10^-5)
FE = 0.672 N


Seriously. I am posting this question.

Here's the answer the book gave:

FE = εq
FE = (5.6*10^4)(-1.2 * 10^-5)
FE = (6.7*10^4) N


It does this again on the answer to the next question, increasing the magnitude by 10^5.

Everything I know tells me I'm right but I need to be sure I'm not doing something very wrong. I don't know why this text is still in circulation if its riddled with this many errors.​
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Did the question supply units to associate with the field and charge values?
 
xxxx
 
Last edited:
charge is in coulombs

field is in Newtons per coulomb
 
xxxx
 
Last edited:
So, coulombs for charge, meters for distances. Looks like your answer is correct and the text is in error.
 
Thanks.

Kind of frustrating, seeing as how we're expected to learn the course solely from the text... which is very inaccurate a lot of the time.
 
What is the text, Halliday and Resnick?
 
Nah. This place makes their own text for Canadian students.
 
Back
Top