Electrodynamic tether on the Moon/Mars?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jumpjack
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electrodynamic
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the feasibility of using an electrodynamic tether on the Moon or Mars to generate electricity by exploiting the solar magnetic field. A long wire placed along the north pole, perpendicular to the Sun, could theoretically cut magnetic field lines and create a voltage difference. The concept involves connecting a second insulated wire to form a closed circuit, potentially generating current, but practical challenges arise, such as the need for a stable setup in space. The conversation also touches on the relationship between tether length, current generation, and the strength of the solar magnetic field, with calculations suggesting that current may depend more on the tether's cross-sectional area than its length. Ultimately, the complexities of electromagnetic principles in space raise questions about the viability of such a system.
jumpjack
Messages
223
Reaction score
3
Moon and Mars have no magnetic field, but that they are immersed into solar magnetic field.
If I place a long wire along north pole, perpendicular to Sun, while Moon/Mars moves along its orbit, the wire cuts magnetic field lines; this should produce a difference of potential between fare edges of the wire... or not?
If I connect a second wire to first one, but I completely insulate it (how?) from solar magnetic field, would I get an electric generator?
Of course the DDP would change during day and year, until it reverses, but a diode could prevent current from flowing in wrong direction.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The current through the diode would charge one end sphere (planet), then stop flowing once the voltage had built up.

A voltage difference is part of the generator, but you can only extract energy while a current flows. Power is the product of voltage and current. You actually need a circuit with a return path, or a loop. There is no need for Mars, the loop can start and end at Earth. There is no insulation required on the wire, space is good enough.

There will be a force on the generator wire that will push it sideways. The coils in an electric generator must be held firmly on the armature or field. You must fix the wire loop in space, so it does not move relative to the Earth.

Unfortunately the Moon does not rotate relative to the Earth, or we could wind a wire once around the armature Moon and use the Earth's magnetic field to generate power on the Moon, until we extracted all the energy and stopped the moon rotating.
 
I think you completely misunderstood my post.
Forget Mars.
Just replace "Moon/Mars" by "Moon" in the post above.

Look at the picture:
sk-adcf031c2f5bea72fd0dabd285e9648f.jpg


Will electrons in the wire be moved along it by Lorentz force?
If I connect a second wire parallel to the first one, but completely isolated shielded from solar magnetic field, will I have a closed circuit containing a generator?

sk-511000e9120a4e1f8f0834ffb5248f04.jpg
 
Baluncore said:
The current through the diode would charge one end sphere (planet), then stop flowing once the voltage had built up.
If a coaxial system were used with an iron cylinder in between the conductors, I have a feeling there could be a constant current flowing along inner and outer conductors due to the different fields and hence different emf's generated in inner and outer conductors. But Electromagnetism is not intuitive so I could be just plain wrong. ??
 
I eventually found some equations to work with:
https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/aeronau...2015/lecture-notes/MIT16_522S15_Lecture25.pdf

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/...SASP.476...61I&defaultprint=YES&filetype=.pdf

If I understand correctly, the Difference Of Potential in the tether is given by:
Voc = v * B * L
v = perpendicular tether speed across EM [m/s]
B = EM field [Tesla]
L = tether length [m]

And the current in the tether, disregarding the "ionosphere items", as we are on the Moon:
I = Voc / Rt
Rt = tether resistance

Hence:
I = v*B*L/Rt

But
Rt = rho * L / A
rho = resistivity
L = length
A = section area

hence:

I = v * B * A / rho (no more "L")

being:
A= 3.14 * r^2 [m^2]
rho = 1.68E-08 [Ohm*m]

I = 3.14/rho * v * B * r^2 = 1.86E08 * v * B * r^2

Orbit speed of Moon around Sun can be assumed as the same of Earth, 108000 km/h, i.e. ~30000 m/s:
v = 3E+04 [m/s]

Sun EM on Moon should be around 1E-09 [T] (confirmations?)
B = 1E-09 [T]

So:
I = 1.86E08 * 3E+04 * 1E-09 * r^2

I = 5.58E+03 * r^2

This is a weird result, as the final current would depend just on tether section and not on its length...
Is this result correct?

Assuming a 10mm radius tether (10^-2 m), we would get:

I = 5.58E+03 * 1E-4

I = 0.558 Ampere (regardless of length)

If it is true that tether length does not matter (and I can't see how it could), if I'd get a block of copper 1m x 1m x 1m, would it generate 5580A?!?
 
jumpjack said:
v = perpendicular tether speed across EM [m/s]
Be careful here. That is the velocity relative to the field. In the case of the Earth-moon system, the field moves with the objects, so if the tether was attached to the Earth-Moon, it would rotate with the field and the velocity relative to the field is zero.
 
anorlunda said:
Be careful here. That is the velocity relative to the field.
To the SUN field, I am talking about Sun EMF.
 
nobody can help?
 
Back
Top