B Eroding Metal with very small forces

  • B
  • Thread starter Thread starter kolleamm
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Forces Metal
AI Thread Summary
Tapping an iron piece with a finger over millions of years could eventually create a dent, as each tap displaces iron atoms. However, this process would need to occur in a water and oxygen-free environment to prevent rusting, which would hinder the effect. While rocks in streams smooth out due to flowing water, iron can resist deformation under small forces for extended periods, approaching an infinite cycle of deformation. Over extremely long timescales, iron may sublimate atom by atom if not otherwise damaged. The discussion highlights the slow but possible erosion of metal under consistent, minimal force.
kolleamm
Messages
476
Reaction score
44
Consider we have an iron piece. If we could somehow tap on the iron with our finger for a very long long time, I mean millions of years, would it ever be able to make a dent?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yes. Assuming your finger stays healthy and regenerates to keep tapping. Every tap pushes some iron atoms to the side.

You might want to do that in a water and oxygen-free environment, otherwise it will rust way before you see any effect from tapping.
 
Rocks in streams are smooth because the flowing water gradually wears them away.
 
True but I remember reading something about iron being able to resist infinite cycles of deformation if they are small enough. It was on the topic of elastic limit.
 
Infinite for all practical purposes, not actually infinite.
On extremely long timescales, the iron will sublimate atom by atom if nothing else destroys it before.
 
  • Like
Likes kolleamm
Thanks for the answer. That makes sense.
 
Back
Top