Find Vx using node voltage method

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a student's incorrect application of the node voltage method in a circuit analysis problem. The main issue identified is the polarity of the 30V source, which the student initially misrepresented in their KCL equation. A participant points out that the first term should be corrected to reflect the proper polarity, specifically stating it should be (Vx + 30) / 5. The student acknowledges the mistake and expresses gratitude for the clarification. This exchange highlights the importance of accurately representing voltage sources in circuit equations.
Samira
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Capture.PNG
is= 1.2 mA

i submitted my solution but it was wrong,can someone please explain why?

/* i just wanted to check if my solution is correct so i don't lose marks on my homework
did i do any mistakes ?
if so please explain.*/
my solution:
IMG_20170320_221725.jpg
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I haven't gone through all your working but check the polarity of the 30V source and the first term in the KCL equation.
 
Hi Samira,

Welcome to Physics Forums!

In future be sure to use the homework formatting template that is provided in the edit window when a new thread is started here in a homework forum. It is one of the rules of the forums and you will find your posts deleted if it is not used.

Regarding your question, your work and result look fine.
 
alright, I'm sorry and thank you for your answer.
 
I still think the first term should be (Vx - (-30)) / 5

For example to be consistent with the third term (Vx-(+80))/1
 
  • Like
Likes Samira
CWatters said:
I still think the first term should be (Vx - (-30)) / 5

For example to be consistent with the third term (Vx-(+80))/1
Argh! You're right! I missed the reversed polarity on the 30 V supply o:) Good catch.

@Samira : The first term in your node equation needs to be fixed. It should be ##\frac{V_x + 30}{5}## .
 
  • Like
Likes Samira
CWatters said:
I still think the first term should be (Vx - (-30)) / 5

For example to be consistent with the third term (Vx-(+80))/1
i'm sorry i did not see your answer last night , i thought i only got one.
thank you !
 

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Back
Top