jeebs
- 314
- 5
Here is the problem:
Use the fact that the form factor, F(q), is the Fourier transform of the normalised charge
distribution \rho(r), which in the spherically symmetric case gives
F(q) = \int \frac{4\pi \hbar r}{q}\rho(r) sin(qr/\hbar))dr
to find an expression for F(q) for a simple model of the proton considered as a uniform
spherical charge distribution of radius R.
Using your calculated expression for F(q), demonstrate that in the limit
\frac{qR}{\hbar} << 1
the form factor reduces to 1.
So, what I have tried so far:
I said that for 0 < r < R, the charge density is constant, and could be taken outside the integral along with the other constants, leaving me with
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar \rho}{q}\int^R_0 r.sin(qr/\hbar)dr
which when I integrate by parts leads to
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar^3 \rho}{q^3}sin(qR/\hbar) - \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2}cos(qR/\hbar)
I am certain that I have done the integration correctly.
Then I come to the part where I make the approximation that \frac{qR}{\hbar} << 1 and this happens:
sin(qR/\hbar) \approx qR/\hbar
and
cos(qR/\hbar) \approx 1
which gives me
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2} - \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2} = 0
but I am supposed to be getting F(q) = 1 when I make this approximation.
What am I doing wrong here? My only thought was that the question mentions something about normalization, and I thought that may have something to do with something, but I couln't think what. Any suggestions?
Thanks.
Use the fact that the form factor, F(q), is the Fourier transform of the normalised charge
distribution \rho(r), which in the spherically symmetric case gives
F(q) = \int \frac{4\pi \hbar r}{q}\rho(r) sin(qr/\hbar))dr
to find an expression for F(q) for a simple model of the proton considered as a uniform
spherical charge distribution of radius R.
Using your calculated expression for F(q), demonstrate that in the limit
\frac{qR}{\hbar} << 1
the form factor reduces to 1.
So, what I have tried so far:
I said that for 0 < r < R, the charge density is constant, and could be taken outside the integral along with the other constants, leaving me with
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar \rho}{q}\int^R_0 r.sin(qr/\hbar)dr
which when I integrate by parts leads to
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar^3 \rho}{q^3}sin(qR/\hbar) - \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2}cos(qR/\hbar)
I am certain that I have done the integration correctly.
Then I come to the part where I make the approximation that \frac{qR}{\hbar} << 1 and this happens:
sin(qR/\hbar) \approx qR/\hbar
and
cos(qR/\hbar) \approx 1
which gives me
F(q) = \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2} - \frac{4\pi \hbar^2 \rho R}{q^2} = 0
but I am supposed to be getting F(q) = 1 when I make this approximation.
What am I doing wrong here? My only thought was that the question mentions something about normalization, and I thought that may have something to do with something, but I couln't think what. Any suggestions?
Thanks.