Finding Force on 7.7 kg Block in Contact with 9.2 kg Block | Physics Problem

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving three blocks in contact, being pushed across a rough horizontal surface by a force of 98 N. The objective is to find the force exerted on a 7.7 kg block by a 9.2 kg block, considering the effects of friction with a coefficient of 0.082 and the acceleration due to gravity at 9.8 m/s².

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss calculating normal forces and frictional forces for each block, questioning the consistency of force across the system. Some suggest using free body diagrams to analyze forces acting on each block individually. Others explore the implications of acceleration being constant across the blocks and the interactions between them.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, sharing calculations and questioning their reasoning. Some have provided guidance on the importance of considering the interactions between blocks and the effects of friction and inertia. There is a recognition of the need for clarity in the application of Newton's laws and the relationships between the forces acting on the blocks.

Contextual Notes

There are indications of confusion regarding the application of friction and the net forces acting on each block. Participants are also reflecting on the accuracy of their calculations and the assumptions made in their reasoning.

GiantSheeps
Messages
83
Reaction score
7

Homework Statement


Three blocks in contact with each other are
pushed across a rough horizontal surface by a
98 N force as shown.
The acceleration of gravity is 9.8 m/s^2. ----F--->|2kg| |7.7kg| |9.2kg|
u = 0.082If the coefficient of kinetic friction between
each of the blocks and the surface is 0.082,
find the magnitude of the force exerted on the
7.7 kg block by the 9.2 kg block.
Answer in units of N

Homework Equations


f=ma
fk=uN

The Attempt at a Solution


So i added the three masses and multiplied all of that by that acceleration due to gravity to get a normal force of 185.22
i multiplied that number by the friction to get 15.18804, and since that was the force going to the left, i subtracted that from 98 to get 82.81196

i thought that would work as a final answer because force would be consistent throughout the system, right? but i got it wrong. where did i go wrong? did i miss a step? is there something more that i need to do?

(also i tried to recreate the diagram with just typing characters, the | | are supposed to represent the blocks)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Separate the blocks and do a free body diagram for each one, starting with the 2 kg block.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: GiantSheeps
GiantSheeps said:

Homework Statement


Three blocks in contact with each other are
pushed across a rough horizontal surface by a
98 N force as shown.
The acceleration of gravity is 9.8 m/s^2.----F--->|2kg| |7.7kg| |9.2kg|
u = 0.082If the coefficient of kinetic friction between
each of the blocks and the surface is 0.082,
find the magnitude of the force exerted on the
7.7 kg block by the 9.2 kg block.
Answer in units of N

Homework Equations


f=ma
fk=uN

The Attempt at a Solution


So i added the three masses and multiplied all of that by that acceleration due to gravity to get a normal force of 185.22
i multiplied that number by the friction to get 15.18804, and since that was the force going to the left, i subtracted that from 98 to get 82.81196

i thought that would work as a final answer because force would be consistent throughout the system, right? but i got it wrong. where did i go wrong? did i miss a step? is there something more that i need to do?

(also i tried to recreate the diagram with just typing characters, the | | are supposed to represent the blocks)

No, force isn't a constant on all blocks. What is a constant is that each block accelerates at the same rate. Use that.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: GiantSheeps
okay so for the first block
weight is 2(9.8) = 19.6
normal force is 2(9.8) = 19.6
and friction force is .082(19.6) = 1.6072
force is 98

so 98 - 1.6072 = 96.3920 is net force

using f=ma

96.3920 = 2a
96.3920 / 2 = 48.1964

so a = 48.1964 m/s^2? that seems a bit too high, where did i go wrong? or is that actually the acceleration?
 
am i even using friction correctly?
 
You forgot to include the fact that the two other blocks are pushing on the first block. Both with friction and their inertia. Hint: like Dick said, acceleration is the same for all blocks.

Take the time to do the free body diagram for each block, one at a time.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: GiantSheeps
okay so taking into account what you all said i added up the masses of each block and got 18.9kg, i multiplied that number by 9.8 to get the normal force, which was 185.22 i multiplied that by .082 to get the frictional force, which got me 15.18804, then i subtracted that number from 98 to get the net force, which was 82.1196, which i divided by 18.9 to get the acceleration of the whole system, which was 4.38 and since acceleration is constant throughout the entire system, i used that number to get the net force on each block

so i got 2kg block = 8.76N
7.7 kg block = 33.738N
9.2 kg block = 40.31N

i then used all this to draw the free body diagrams, now, would i add the net force of the 7.7kg block to that of the 9.2 kg block? Or would the answer simply the net force of the 7.7kg block since every action has an equal and opposite reaction so the 7.7 kg block pushes on the 9.2 kg block with a force of 33.738N, wouldn't the 9.2 kg block push back with that same force?

(I might have missed some details when actually drawing the diagrams, free body diagrams have never really been my strong suit)
 
GiantSheeps said:
okay so taking into account what you all said i added up the masses of each block and got 18.9kg, i multiplied that number by 9.8 to get the normal force, which was 185.22 i multiplied that by .082 to get the frictional force, which got me 15.18804, then i subtracted that number from 98 to get the net force, which was 82.1196, which i divided by 18.9 to get the acceleration of the whole system, which was 4.38 and since acceleration is constant throughout the entire system, i used that number to get the net force on each block

so i got 2kg block = 8.76N
7.7 kg block = 33.738N
9.2 kg block = 40.31N

i then used all this to draw the free body diagrams, now, would i add the net force of the 7.7kg block to that of the 9.2 kg block? Or would the answer simply the net force of the 7.7kg block since every action has an equal and opposite reaction so the 7.7 kg block pushes on the 9.2 kg block with a force of 33.738N, wouldn't the 9.2 kg block push back with that same force?

(I might have missed some details when actually drawing the diagrams, free body diagrams have never really been my strong suit)

or i just realized, perhaps i would subtract the net force of the 9.2 block by the net force of the 7.7 block to get 6.53N?
 
Sorry, I had to go to bed at one point.
GiantSheeps said:
okay so taking into account what you all said i added up the masses of each block and got 18.9kg, i multiplied that number by 9.8 to get the normal force, which was 185.22 i multiplied that by .082 to get the frictional force, which got me 15.18804, then i subtracted that number from 98 to get the net force, which was 82.1196, which i divided by 18.9 to get the acceleration of the whole system, which was 4.38 and since acceleration is constant throughout the entire system, i used that number to get the net force on each block

so i got 2kg block = 8.76N
7.7 kg block = 33.738N
9.2 kg block = 40.31N
All good.
GiantSheeps said:
i then used all this to draw the free body diagrams, now, would i add the net force of the 7.7kg block to that of the 9.2 kg block? Or would the answer simply the net force of the 7.7kg block since every action has an equal and opposite reaction so the 7.7 kg block pushes on the 9.2 kg block with a force of 33.738N, wouldn't the 9.2 kg block push back with that same force?
I already answered that:
jack action said:
You forgot to include the fact that the two other blocks are pushing on the first block. Both with friction and their inertia.

Similarly, the middle block has the first block pushing on one of its side (considering friction and inertia, plus the 98 N force) and the last block pushing on its other side (considering friction and inertia); The last block has the other two blocks pushing on one of its side only (considering friction and inertia, plus the 98 N force). That last sum of forces is the «magnitude of the force exerted on the 7.7 kg block by the 9.2 kg block» that you are looking for (as well as the magnitude of the force exerted on the 9.2 kg block by the 7.7 kg block).
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K