Finding the Max Value of a Function on a closed interval

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the maximum value of a function defined by the equation C(t) = C + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) for t in the interval [3,12], where a, b, and C are constants. Participants explore the conditions under which maxima and minima occur, particularly focusing on the derivative of the function.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the process of taking the derivative to find critical points and question the validity of using logarithmic properties in their attempts. There is a focus on the implications of setting the derivative to zero and the potential for extrema at the endpoints of the interval.

Discussion Status

Several participants have provided guidance on the correct approach to manipulating the equation and have pointed out misconceptions regarding logarithmic properties. The conversation reflects a mix of interpretations and attempts to clarify the mathematical reasoning involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that one of the constants a or b must be negative for certain conditions to hold, and there is an ongoing discussion about the implications of this on the solution process. The conversation also highlights the importance of understanding the behavior of the function at the endpoints of the interval.

danbone87
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
[SOLVED] Finding the Max Value of a Function on a closed interval

Homework Statement



Hi, I'm reposting this because it's a subsection to a larger question I had and I figured more people might be able to help with a new topic name.

anyway i have the equation (eq1) C(t) = C + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0 [3,12]

a,b and C are constants.


The Attempt at a Solution



I realized from long ago that the max and mins of a function occur when y'=0

So I took the derivative of the function which gave me

C(t) = Css + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0

c'(t)= .5a(e^.5t) + .9b(e^.9t) = 0

i took the ln of the whole thing

and that gave me

[ln(.5a)*.5t] + [ln(.9b)*.9t] = 0

my question now is can use the property that ln(xy) = ln(x)+ln(y) to combine the two ln's and thereby combining the coeffiecients of t such that it is .5t+.9t = .14t

and the whole thing would be .14t*ln(.45ab)= 0

... that seems to be wrong considering that the t's cancel out but I can't think of much else...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
danbone87 said:

Homework Statement



Hi, I'm reposting this because it's a subsection to a larger question I had and I figured more people might be able to help with a new topic name.

anyway i have the equation (eq1) C(t) = C + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0 [3,12]

a,b and C are constants.


The Attempt at a Solution



I realized from long ago that the max and mins of a function occur when y'=0
Not quite. If the max and/or min occur in the interior of an interval, they must occur where y'= 0. The max and/or min may occur at the endpoints of the interval.

So I took the derivative of the function which gave me

C(t) = Css + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0

c'(t)= .5a(e^.5t) + .9b(e^.9t) = 0

i took the ln of the whole thing

and that gave me

[ln(.5a)*.5t] + [ln(.9b)*.9t] = 0
No, no no! Ln(x+ y) is NOT ln(x)+ ln(y)!
You could write it as .5ae.5t= -.9be.9t and take logs of both sides of that. Be careful about signs. One of a and b must be negative but you don't know which one. Either .5ae.5t= -.9be.9t or -.5ae.5t= .9be.9t gives you positive numbers on each side so you can use logarithms. Try both and see what happens.

my question now is can use the property that ln(xy) = ln(x)+ln(y) to combine the two ln's and thereby combining the coeffiecients of t such that it is .5t+.9t = .14t

and the whole thing would be .14t*ln(.45ab)= 0

... that seems to be wrong considering that the t's cancel out but I can't think of much else...
Yes, that is wrong!
 
The 'taking the ln of the whole thing' is a completely wrong move. E.g. ln(0)=-infinity and there is no rule that says ln(a+b)=ln(a)+ln(b). Rearrange the equation first. Start by writing .5*a*e^(.5*t)=-.9*b*e^(.9*t). Now move all of the e^ type things over to one side and everything else over to the other. Now 'take the ln of the whole thing'.
 
danbone87 said:

Homework Statement



Hi, I'm reposting this because it's a subsection to a larger question I had and I figured more people might be able to help with a new topic name.

anyway i have the equation (eq1) C(t) = C + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0 [3,12]

a,b and C are constants.


The Attempt at a Solution



I realized from long ago that the max and mins of a function occur when y'=0
Not quite. If the max and/or min occur in the interior of an interval, they must occur where y'= 0. The max and/or min may occur at the endpoints of the interval.

So I took the derivative of the function which gave me

C(t) = Css + a(e^.5t) + b(e^.9t) t>0

c'(t)= .5a(e^.5t) + .9b(e^.9t) = 0

i took the ln of the whole thing

and that gave me

[ln(.5a)*.5t] + [ln(.9b)*.9t] = 0
No, no no! Ln(x+ y) is NOT ln(x)+ ln(y)!
I recommend factoring out e.5t: e.5t(.5a+ .9be.4t)= 0. Since e.5t is never 0, you must have .5a+ .9be.4t= 0. That should be easy to solve for t. Of course, one of a and b must be negative for this to be true.


my question now is can use the property that ln(xy) = ln(x)+ln(y) to combine the two ln's and thereby combining the coeffiecients of t such that it is .5t+.9t = .14t

and the whole thing would be .14t*ln(.45ab)= 0

... that seems to be wrong considering that the t's cancel out but I can't think of much else...
Yes, that is wrong!
 
Should've kept those calc books thanks for the help guys
 
Just to clarify, I said that the ln(x*y) = ln(x) +ln(y) not ln(x+y)

that is correct isn't it?
 
That's correct. That's what you SAID. If you look back at what you actually USED, it was ln(x+y)=ln(x)+ln(y) (?) when you 'took the ln of the whole thing'.
 
yeah, I figured that. It just comes into play right after when I seprate these t's out so i wanted to double check. Thanks again.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K