Have we been able to land a rocket upright?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
11 replies · 2K views
hsdrop
Messages
324
Reaction score
114
just an odd question that passed through my mind when i was watching a SpaceX youtube vid have we (as in humans)ever gotten a rocket to land on the ground with the nose up and the thrusters down (the same position the rocket took of in)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Simon Bridge said:
... wasn't that the vid you just watched? How about this one:

the one i watched was a little older and it was animated so i was not share that they had done it or not
 
hsdrop said:
just an odd question that passed through my mind when i was watching a SpaceX youtube vid have we (as in humans)ever gotten a rocket to land on the ground with the nose up and the thrusters down (the same position the rocket took of in)?
Apollo 11-17 did that with only one failure...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters
i was not share that they had done it or not
Perhaps if you refined your question? It is unclear how you could be unaware/unsure of this:

(Off the question as asked...)
Apollo LLRV, probably doesn't count since it had no rocket engines (?)
Apollo LM landed rockets down, nose up - took off from the ground the same way.
Does the surface of the Moon count as "ground" here?
It landed and then took off ... does that count, or does it have to be take-off first?​

Apollo LLTV did have rockets, landed the same way it took off, and the take-off was first.

Also: search for vtol and vtvl rockets will get you lots of examples...
 
i was just making sure that we were keeping a head of this guy!
marvin riding rocket.gif

I was also in awe of the beaut that humans have been able to sculpt their dreams into reality
 
Simon Bridge said:
Those humans huh? All that creativity, and tasty too...
Pretty soon we'll have accidents where the rocket sinks into the launch platform because the pilot had it in reverse...
HAY MEN SOME ONE TOLD ME "R" WAS FOR RACE
 
And, I bet you believed them and crashed into someones house too, didn't you? :doh:
 
Simon Bridge said:
(Off the question as asked...)
Apollo LLRV, probably doesn't count since it had no rocket engines (?)
Apollo LM landed rockets down, nose up - took off from the ground the same way.
Does the surface of the Moon count as "ground" here?
It landed and then took off ... does that count, or does it have to be take-off first?​
How is my post "Off the question as asked...?"

I neglected to mention the LM took off from Earth before it landed on the moon. No requirement in the OP for the engine to be running during take off.

Several mentions of [lunar] ground in APOLLO OVER THE MOON: A VIEW FROM ORBIT (NASA SP-362) so ground seems the right term.
 
Last edited: