Heat and work -- how much energy to climb the rope....

AI Thread Summary
A standard man climbing 15 m up a vertical rope requires energy calculated using the formula Q = mgΔh, where m is mass and g is gravitational acceleration. The discussion centers on the confusion regarding the interpretation of the 23% of total energy used for work, with some participants questioning if the wording is accurate. It is clarified that 23% refers to the energy expended that contributes to the ascent, not the total energy required. Participants suggest creating an unknown variable to represent the total energy expended to solve the problem. The conversation highlights the importance of clear wording in physics problems for accurate understanding and calculation.
Sam Vermeulen
Messages
5
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A standard man climbs 15 m up a vertical rope. How much energy (in cal) is dissipated as heat in a single climb if 23% of the total energy required is used to do the work? (Assume the standard man has a mass of 70 kg.)

Homework Equations


Q = mgΔh

The Attempt at a Solution


I used Q = mgΔh and took 23% of that and then converted it to calories and it was not correct. I think I am just not understanding what the question is asking for.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Sam Vermeulen said:
if 23% of the total energy required is used to do the work?
That part doesn't make any sense. Is it copied word-for-word? Are you sure it's not 123%? How could it take less work than the change in energy?
 
berkeman said:
That part doesn't make any sense. Is it copied word-for-word? Are you sure it's not 123%? How could it take less work than the change in energy?
The wording is unclear, but I would it interpret as 23% of the energy the man expends goes into the useful work of ascending the rope.
 
Ah, that would make a lot more sense! Thanks haruspex.
 
berkeman said:
That part doesn't make any sense. Is it copied word-for-word? Are you sure it's not 123%? How could it take less work than the change in energy?
Yeah copied it word for word I'll try what haruspex said. Thank you for the help.
 
haruspex said:
The wording is unclear, but I would it interpret as 23% of the energy the man expends goes into the useful work of ascending the rope.
How would I go about this without knowing the amount of energy the man expended in the first place?
 
Sam Vermeulen said:
How would I go about this without knowing the amount of energy the man expended in the first place?
Just create an unknown for that and see what equation you can write.
 
Back
Top