Heat conduction in hollow cilinder.

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a heat conduction problem in a hollow cylinder with varying inner and outer radii. Participants analyze the heat flow and temperature gradient, noting that the changing area complicates the calculations. The key equation for heat flux is highlighted, emphasizing the need for integration to determine the temperature profile. There is a realization that the logarithmic approach to finding temperature is incorrect without proper unit consideration. Ultimately, the conversation reveals the importance of correctly applying thermal equations to derive heat flow and temperature gradients in cylindrical geometries.
aranud
Messages
20
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Given is a hollow cilinder with inner radius R1 and outer radius R2. The heat conductivity of the material is k. The cilinder has length l and an inner temperature of T1 and outer temperature T2. Determine the temperature gradient in the cilinder and the heat flow that leaks away radially.

Homework Equations


Power = k*Area(Temperatureinside-Temperatureoutside)/(thickness)
Area = 2*pi*R*l

The Attempt at a Solution


The reason I can't solve this problem is the changing area when going from inside to outside the cilinder. Obviously the heat flow going from the inside to the outside should be minus the heat flow from outside to inside, since the areas are different I think the only way this is possible if the temperature gradient falls off quicker going inside causing the heat flow to be the equal despite the smaller area.
So much for intuition though since I've tried fruitlessly to write this down mathematically.
I also think the trick is to use an intermediate temperature T and equate the powers going through an area between R2 and R1 since we've used that one before.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
aranud said:
Power = k*Area(Temperatureinside-Temperatureoutside)/(thickness)

This equation assumes that the temperature profile is linear, which isn't the case here. A more general equation is \mathrm{Heat~flux}=kA(x)(dT/dx), or since you're working with radius r, \mathrm{Heat~flux}=kA(r)(dT/dr). You should be able to find T(r) through integration.
 
When I integrate the formula you've given me I get T = (heat flux)/(k*2pi*l)*ln(R)
To find the heat flux should i simply fill in T1 and R1? I feel like I've missed something since the problem seems a bit simple this way.
 
aranud said:
When I integrate the formula you've given me I get T = (heat flux)/(k*2pi*l)*ln(R)
To find the heat flux should i simply fill in T1 and R1? I feel like I've missed something since the problem seems a bit simple this way.

Check your integration. A lone ln(R) can't be correct; you can't take the logarithm of a parameter with units.
 
You're right, is this better? T = T1+ heatflux/(k*2*pi*l)*ln(r/R1)
It seems to describe the right heat gradient but how do I get the heatflux from this?
 
You know the temperature at the outer radius too.
 
Ah yes of course:blushing: My brain is all but melted right now because of all the studying I guess. Thanks for the help.
 
Back
Top