Heat transfer between resistance and water

AI Thread Summary
The main mechanism of heat transfer between a thermal resistance and water is conduction, despite the presence of convection in the surrounding fluid. While copper is an excellent thermal conductor, the heat transfer from the solid surface of the resistance to the water occurs primarily through conduction at the interface. Convection plays a role in the overall heat transfer process, especially in the water, but it is not the primary mechanism between the solid and the liquid. The confusion arises from differing definitions of convection, which can include the effects of fluid motion and conduction together. Understanding this distinction clarifies why conduction is emphasized in the context of heat transfer from the resistance to the water.
Carcul
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
What is the *main* mechanism of heat transfer between a thermal resistance and water?

My doubt arose in the context of a problem (from a high school national test) dealing with the following situation: a 500 W thermal resistance made of copper is immersed in a jar containing 500 g of water at 20ºC, with the purpose of heating it to 90ºC, and then it is asked what is the principal mechanism of heat transfer between the resistance and the water.

Even being copper a very goog thermal conductor, we have here heat transfer between a fluid and a hot solid surface, so shouldn't it be mainly by convection? The correct answer is supposed to be "conduction", but I don't agree.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why do you say it is convection??

More importantly, why did you even consider convection? it never occurs in something where diffusion currents(of mass) cannot flow.
 
Now you have confused me. Why can't occur here mass transport of water? Isn't it a fluid??!
 
Carcul said:
Now you have confused me. Why can't occur here mass transport of water? Isn't it a fluid??!

Water is a fluid, and heat transfer in water takes place by convection, mostly.

But your question is, what is the method of heat transfer between a solid copper resistance and liquid water.. How can convection currents arise in solids and be transferred to liquids?? :wink:
 
Thank you very much for your help, I understand now what you meant. I guess my source of confusion is/was the way convection is defined in some books. For instance, in the book Thermodynamics, an engineering approach, from Çengel, we can read "Convection is the transfer of energy between a solid surface and the adjacent fluid that is in motion, and it involves the combined effects of conduction and fluid motion." This doesn't look like the explanation you have given, however.
 
I was using the Smith chart to determine the input impedance of a transmission line that has a reflection from the load. One can do this if one knows the characteristic impedance Zo, the degree of mismatch of the load ZL and the length of the transmission line in wavelengths. However, my question is: Consider the input impedance of a wave which appears back at the source after reflection from the load and has traveled for some fraction of a wavelength. The impedance of this wave as it...
Back
Top