How do the charges in 3 cancel each other out in net electrostatic force?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding how charges in a system can affect the net electrostatic force on a central charge. It highlights that positive charges repel while negative charges attract, leading to a complex interaction where forces can either add or subtract. The example of two friends, one pulling and the other pushing, illustrates how these forces do not necessarily cancel out. The net force on the center charge is determined by the direction and magnitude of the forces exerted by surrounding charges. Ultimately, the center charge experiences the highest net force when accounting for these interactions.
Salman Ali
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Member advised to use the formatting template for all homework help requests
Here is the question no1 in image. A charge is in between . We will let it possitive or negative. The answer is 3,1,2 4...But how? Won't the charges in 3 cancel each other out because they are possitive at right and negative at left. One is attracting so the other is repelling.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20181225_190625.jpg
    Screenshot_20181225_190625.jpg
    28.4 KB · Views: 334
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Salman Ali said:
One is attracting so the other is repelling.
And what direction is the force that each exerts on the center charge? (Do they add or subtract?)
 
Doc Al said:
And what direction is the force that each exerts on the centre charge? (Do they add or subtract?)
if we let the centre charge to be positive then obviously the negative ones will attract it while the positive ones will repel it. Now the question is about the net electrostatic force. See these explanations.
 

Attachments

  • 1st answer.PNG
    1st answer.PNG
    14 KB · Views: 450
  • 2nd.PNG
    2nd.PNG
    6.2 KB · Views: 349
Salman Ali said:
if we let the centre charge to be positive then obviously the negative ones will attract it while the positive ones will repel it.
Well, then what is your question?
 
Doc Al said:
Well, then what is your question?
I am still not getting it. Can you explain how in 3 the center has the highest net force?
 
Figure out the direction of the force that each charge exerts on the center charge.

Imagine this: One friend on your right pulls you toward him while a friend on your left pushes you away. Do those pushes/pulls cancel?
 
Doc Al said:
Figure out the direction of the force that each charge exerts on the center charge.

Imagine this: One friend on your right pulls you toward him while a friend on your left pushes you away. Do those pushes/pulls cancel?
Got it bro! Thanks!
 
Back
Top