docnet
- 796
- 486
How does LHC send same-charged particles in opposite directions?
The discussion focuses on how the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) manages to send same-charged particles, specifically protons, in opposite directions for collisions. It covers the mechanisms involved in beam transport, the structure of the beam pipes, and the role of detectors in observing collisions.
Participants generally agree on the basic mechanics of how the LHC operates with counter-propagating beams, but there is disagreement regarding the classification and operational details of the LHCb experiment, particularly its fixed target capabilities.
Some statements about LHCb's operational modes and the nature of collisions are nuanced and depend on specific conditions, leading to potential misunderstandings among participants.
... and LHCb, to complete the list of the big detectors.ChrisVer said:At points where we collide protons we built the detectos such as ALICE, ATLAS and CMS.
mfb said:... and LHCb, to complete the list of the big detectors.
They would if they were traveling through the same magnet, but they are not. As is shown in the picture handily posted by @ChrisVer, the counter propagating beams are traveling in separate beam pipes, with separate magnets.Meir Achuz said:With the same charges, wouldn't the beams be bent in two different circles by the magnetic field?
Generally LHCb sees collisions of whatever the LHC is circulation (p-p, Pb-Pb, etc.) but at a lower luminosity than what ATLAS and CMS see.ChrisVer said:Because the LHCb is a fixed target experiment (so the beam protons are not brought together).
ChrisVer said:well yes, maybe I should rephrase it to "we collide protons with each other". Because the LHCb is a fixed target experiment (so the beam protons are not brought together).