How far apart are the astronaut and satellite after 8.67 minutes?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a spacewalking astronaut pushing off a satellite and seeks to determine the distance between them after 8.67 minutes. The scenario includes the astronaut's mass, the satellite's mass, the force exerted, and the duration of the push.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss finding the acceleration of both the astronaut and the satellite using Newton's second law and question the initial conditions necessary for calculations. There is exploration of the astronaut's motion during and after the push, as well as the impact of the time of contact on the final velocity.

Discussion Status

Participants have engaged in a back-and-forth regarding the calculations needed to find the astronaut's acceleration and subsequent velocity. Some guidance has been provided on the assumptions regarding initial velocities and the relevance of the time of contact, leading to a clearer understanding of the problem's dynamics.

Contextual Notes

There is an assumption that the astronaut starts from rest relative to the satellite, though this is not explicitly stated in the problem. The discussion also highlights the small displacement of the satellite compared to that of the astronaut.

alexi_b
Messages
49
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


A 63.8kg spacewalking astronaut pushes off a 678.0kg satellite, exerting a 156.0N force for the 0.870s it takes him to straighten his arms. How far apart are the astronaut and the satellite after 8.67min?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I tried just finding the acceleration of the satellite using Fnet=ma and then using that acceleration to place it into d=1/2at^2 (assuming the satellite was at rest) The answer came up into the thousands so I knew I did something wrong. I have no idea of how to start this question so it'd be great if someone could help out!

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
alexi_b said:

Homework Statement


A 63.8kg spacewalking astronaut pushes off a 678.0kg satellite, exerting a 156.0N force for the 0.870s it takes him to straighten his arms. How far apart are the astronaut and the satellite after 8.67min?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I tried just finding the acceleration of the satellite using Fnet=ma and then using that acceleration to place it into d=1/2at^2 (assuming the satellite was at rest) The answer came up into the thousands so I knew I did something wrong. I have no idea of how to start this question so it'd be great if someone could help out!

Thanks!
As you said, the satellite's motion is small compared to the one of the astronaut. Most of the separation will be due to the motion of the astronaut, so you should find his/her acceleration. If they want much precision, then you can take into account the displacement of the satellite but it will be small compared to the one of the astronaut.
 
nrqed said:
As you said, the satellite's motion is small compared to the one of the astronaut. Most of the separation will be due to the motion of the astronaut, so you should find his/her acceleration. If they want much precision, then you can take into account the displacement of the satellite but it will be small compared to the one of the astronaut.

But how can i find the acceleration of the astronaut when I barely know anything about them? Would i just be using Fnet= ma, where m= astronauts mass and Fnet= the force they apply on the satellite?
 
alexi_b said:
But how can i find the acceleration of the astronaut when I barely know anything about them? Would i just be using Fnet= ma, where m= astronauts mass and Fnet= the force they apply on the satellite?
Yes. Recall Newton's third law: fi the astronaut pushes on the satellite by 156 N, the force on the astronaut due to the contact with the satellite is also 156 N.
 
nrqed said:
Yes. Recall Newton's third law: fi the astronaut pushes on the satellite by 156 N, the force on the astronaut due to the contact with the satellite is also 156 N.
Okay gotcha! But if i may ask, what does the time the astronaut have in contact with the satellite have to do with the problem?
 
alexi_b said:
Okay gotcha! But if i may ask, what does the time the astronaut have in contact with the satellite have to do with the problem?
The astronaut accelerates only while pushing, so only during this 0.870 s. After he/she loses contact, he/she will continue moving at constant velocity. So you need to find his/her final velocity after being accelerated during 0.870 s. And then you will use that d = vt with t corresponding to the 8.67 min
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: alexi_b
nrqed said:
The astronaut accelerates only while pushing, so only during this 0.870 s. After he/she loses contact, he/she will continue moving at constant velocity. So you need to find his/her final velocity after being accelerated during 0.870 s. And then you will use that d = vt with t corresponding to the 8.67 min
thanks so much, you've been a great help!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nrqed
nrqed said:
The astronaut accelerates only while pushing, so only during this 0.870 s. After he/she loses contact, he/she will continue moving at constant velocity. So you need to find his/her final velocity after being accelerated during 0.870 s. And then you will use that d = vt with t corresponding to the 8.67 min
Sorry, just another question came up. Do I assume the astronauts initial velocity is 0? Because other than that I don't see any other way of calculating the astronauts final velocity
 
alexi_b said:
Sorry, just another question came up. Do I assume the astronauts initial velocity is 0? Because other than that I don't see any other way of calculating the astronauts final velocity
Good question. Yes, you can. The point is that initially the astronaut is at rest relative to the satellite. In principle it does not have to be this way and the question should have made it clear, but from experience I can tell you that I am sure they assume this.

By the way, I replied to your other question about two blocks on one another.
 
  • #10
nrqed said:
Good question. Yes, you can. The point is that initially the astronaut is at rest relative to the satellite. In principle it does not have to be this way and the question should have made it clear, but from experience I can tell you that I am sure they assume this.

By the way, I replied to your other question about two blocks on one another.
I found the acceleration using the astrounaut to be 2.44 m/s^2
So i just used Vf = Vi + at and solved for Vf which turned out to be 2.12 m/s
This will now become my initial velocity of the satellite.

Using D=vt, d=(2.12m/s)(520.2 s) <-- 8.67 min turned into seconds
and i get 1102.824 m

does this seem correct?
 
  • #11
alexi_b said:
I found the acceleration using the astrounaut to be 2.44 m/s^2
So i just used Vf = Vi + at and solved for Vf which turned out to be 2.12 m/s
This will now become my initial velocity of the satellite.

Using D=vt, d=(2.12m/s)(520.2 s) <-- 8.67 min turned into seconds
and i get 1102.824 m

does this seem correct?
Yes, it is right (You meant "initial velocity of the astronaut").
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: alexi_b

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
19K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K