How would a light saber really work?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nicool003
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light Work
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the feasibility of creating a weapon similar to those depicted in movies, particularly focusing on the concept of an electromagnetic (EM) weapon. While some participants express skepticism about the possibility of replicating such technology exactly as shown in films, they acknowledge that similar weapons could be developed using promising technologies. A notable idea involves utilizing multiple EM wave sources to create intersections where harmful effects could occur, while the waves themselves remain harmless. Additionally, previous discussions highlighted challenges related to plasma-based weapons, including issues with heat, visibility, and efficiency. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the potential for innovative approaches to weapon design while recognizing the technical hurdles that remain.
Nicool003
well since this thread isn't in How Stuff Works yet, and it was put in Technology as a ''somewhat'' duplicate let's start off fresh.

I'll ask these questions although we discussed them a lot in the old PF for all those who haven't seen the thread I will start it off


"do you think it is possible"

"why"

"how"
"do you have any ideas as to how it would/should/could work?"
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
Are u kind of addicted to this stuff Nicool ?
J/K.
Well i remember lot of good ideas were presented in the original versions of this topic.

"do you think it is possible"
I personally think it is not possible as is (like in movies).
But a very similar weapon can be made.

"why"
Because there are lot of promising technologies that could be used

"how"
"do you have any ideas as to how it would/should/could work?"
The best idea i see so far is the idea of having more than a single EM wave source, that will make EM waves that cross at a certain (adjustable) point.
The EM wave itself will be harmless, but at the point of crossing of the two EM waves intersections between waves will happen to produce a new wave that is harmfull (only at that point).

Some technologies could be used to make several points, or maybe a line of those points.
 
True I like star wars...and the technology in it!

Yes in the last thread i believe FZ suggested plasma but as he said (and I quote)

"there are three problems"

1) The handle would get rather *hot*
2) It would glow like a dun and blind poor obi-wan
3) It would parry other sabers but at times would not be so "efficient"
 
And maybe ... it will be too heavy ?
 
perhaps but perhaps not. It could be another form of plasma or perhaps a type of laser. There were many ideas but I am pretty busy now and won't be on PF for long so I will post them later.
 
This week, I saw a documentary done by the French called Les sacrifiés de l'IA, which was presented by a Canadian show Enquête. If you understand French I recommend it. Very eye-opening. I found a similar documentary in English called The Human Cost of AI: Data workers in the Global South. There is also an interview with Milagros Miceli (appearing in both documentaries) on Youtube: I also found a powerpoint presentation by the economist Uma Rani (appearing in the French documentary), AI...

Similar threads

Back
Top