Mathematica 5.1 and Mathcad 12 are powerful software tools that can enhance learning in mathematics, particularly for high school students studying calculus. While some users express skepticism about the necessity of such advanced software at a high school level, others highlight its potential for efficiency in completing homework and understanding complex concepts. Mathematica, in particular, is noted for its extensive documentation and features that can aid in graphing and solving mathematical problems. Users suggest taking advantage of the software's introductory tour to familiarize oneself with its capabilities. There is a discussion about whether using the software for assignments is acceptable, emphasizing the importance of showing work to teachers. Overall, while the software may seem advanced, it can be beneficial for dedicated students willing to invest time in learning how to use it effectively.