Internal energy + entropy for molecule

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
5 replies · 1K views
tonyjk
Messages
227
Reaction score
3
Hello,
Internal energy can be defined theoretically for one molecule (U = 1/2 Kb T) for example but entropy is defined for a system thus for many molecules. Then we define temperature equal to δU / δS but here U can be defined for one molecule, so S can also be defined for one molecule? How?

Thank you
 
Physics news on Phys.org
tonyjk said:
Hello,
Internal energy can be defined theoretically for one molecule (U = 1/2 Kb T) for example but entropy is defined for a system thus for many molecules. Then we define temperature equal to δU / δS but here U can be defined for one molecule, so S can also be defined for one molecule? How?

Thank you
Do you really feel that the equation you presented for U describes the kinetic energy of each and every molecule of an ideal gas, or is it just the average kinetic energy over all the molecules, consistent with the Boltzmann distribution?
 
Chestermiller said:
Do you really feel that the equation you presented for U describes the kinetic energy of each and every molecule of an ideal gas, or is it just the average kinetic energy over all the molecules, consistent with the Boltzmann distribution?
No like I said U can theoretically describe both. For example if U can describe one molecule thus the temperature can describe one molecule. So S can describe one molecule? Then if S cannot describe one molecule, a temperature cannot describe one molecule, so there is a contradiction in the U definition for one molecule
 
Last edited:
The average number of children per family in the US was 2.7 in 1961.
Can you say that any specific family had 2.7 children?
 
DrDu said:
In statistical mechanics, there is nothing wrong with defining entropy for a single molecule.
Great. So how the temperature of one molecule in statistical mechanics is related to macroscopic temperature (T= dU/dS) of a volume containing this molecule and many others?