Is it possible to create a cloaking device using phonon modes in light?

  • Thread starter Thread starter skywolf
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Device Idea
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the possibility of creating a cloaking device using phonon modes in light, focusing on the transparency of glass as a crystal. It is clarified that phonons exist due to the collective behavior of all atoms in a crystal lattice, and photons are the particles that interact with the medium, not phonons. The idea of inducing specific phonon modes to achieve invisibility is questioned, emphasizing that phonons do not interfere with each other in the way suggested. The conversation highlights the distinction between the roles of photons and phonons in the context of light interaction with materials. Overall, the feasibility of using phonon modes for invisibility remains uncertain and requires further exploration.
skywolf
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
would this work?

first of all, i need to know if my reasons for glass being transparent are correct. glass is a crystal, therefore, when the outermost atoms are hit by lthe first photons, the energy, by way of phonons is transferred to the inner atoms as well. when the second photons come by, theyre like "this atom has already been hit by photons and it doesn't fit my vibrational pattern any more" and so they keep going.

now this theory makes sense to most crystals, but I am sure they arent all transparent, just like they don't all perfectly tune into the photons vibrational pattern (wavelenght)

i was wondering if that made any sence, and if so, could you make some sort of fabric that when hit by light, sent phonons into the substance it covered therefore rendering it invisible?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Please read the FAQ in this section of PF.

Zz.
 
yeah, i read it before, i guess this is my way of trying to understand it, i was wondering if it made any sence.
 
"Phonons" exist not just due to one, two, 12, 240, etc. ions in the lattice. It exists due to ALL of them within the crystal. So one can't say that phonons are "transfered" to the inner atoms. It doesn't make much sense. Either that vibrational mode exists, or it doesn't.

It is the photon that is being transported through the medium, not phonons. The existence of phonon modes dictates if the medium can absorb that photon and converts the energy to vibration/heat.

Zz.
 
so if i could "induce" the right kind of phonon mode in myself, would i become invisible?
 
new question

if the photons are making phonon modes, why don't the phonon modes interfere with each other?
i mean if light is coming at glass in one direction and the other one, would it ever interfere with itself?
 
skywolf said:
new question

if the photons are making phonon modes, why don't the phonon modes interfere with each other?
i mean if light is coming at glass in one direction and the other one, would it ever interfere with itself?

Correction! The photons do NOT "make" phonon modes.

Zz.
 
Back
Top