Is this a real graph or is it made up?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gauss44
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Graph
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a T-shirt design featuring a Feynman diagram, specifically depicting beta decay, where a neutron transforms into a proton while emitting a neutrino and an electron. Participants debate the accuracy of the diagram, noting that the arrow direction is incorrect, which raises questions about conservation of charge. While some express curiosity about the physics behind the diagram, others clarify that Feynman diagrams are symbolic representations and do not depict actual particle interactions. The conversation highlights misunderstandings regarding the mass of particles involved in the decay process and the nature of Feynman diagrams. Overall, the thread emphasizes the blend of art and science in the T-shirt design, while critiquing its scientific accuracy.
gauss44
Messages
48
Reaction score
0
http://ypelletier.wordans.ca/t-shirt/feynman-gildan-homme-man-81965

Is this just a cool design or is it a real physics expression (or something that makes sense)?

I figure it might be something like velocity is converted to work and "e-," and work plus "n" equals pressure, or something...
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
It's a feynman diagram. I don't know about them (except what they look like) but I'm pretty sure that is a real diagram. (Although, I don't know what the physics means.)

P.S.
I'm pretty sure the colors are just for the shirt (the colors aren't important to the physics)Edit:
I'm speaking out of ignorance, but:
I think that feynman diagrams are supposed to represent interactions between particles. Beyond that I do not know any details.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
gauss44 said:
http://ypelletier.wordans.ca/t-shirt/feynman-gildan-homme-man-81965

Is this just a cool design or is it a real physics expression (or something that makes sense)?

I figure it might be something like velocity is converted to work and "e-," and work plus "n" equals pressure, or something...

It's a Feynman diagram of a beta decay (a neutron converts to a proton while emitting a neutrino and an electron), rearranged to fit nicely on the T-shirt.
 
Nugatory said:
It's a Feynman diagram of a beta decay (a neutron converts to a proton while emitting a neutrino and an electron), rearranged to fit nicely on the T-shirt.

Too bad they couldn't at least point the arrow in the correct direction.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/89/Beta_Negative_Decay.svg

Perhaps it's a nerd test.

"Hey! That should be a positive W-boson. And that should be an anti-electron neutrino. And the arrow implies non-compliance of conservation of charge. Your shirt is not even wrong!"
 
Wow, thanks everyone. What a neat diagram.
 
OmCheeto said:
Too bad they couldn't at least point the arrow in the correct direction.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/89/Beta_Negative_Decay.svg

Perhaps it's a nerd test.

"Hey! That should be a positive W-boson. And that should be an anti-electron neutrino. And the arrow implies non-compliance of conservation of charge. Your shirt is not even wrong!"

Yeah, this makes sense, I think. A neutron separates into two particles, +1 proton and -1 electron. The added neutrino's mass might contribute to the electron's mass. By E=MC^2, the negative work, might contribute to the remaining mass needed for the electron.

What do you all think?
 
Last edited:
gauss44 said:
Yeah, this makes sense, I think. A neutron separates into two particles, +1 proton and -1 electron. The added neutrino's mass might contribute to the electron's mass. By E=MC^2, the negative work, might contribute to the remaining mass needed for the electron.

What do you all think?

Nope. The neutron has greater mass than the proton, the neutrino has negligible mass, and the neutrino is emitted in the reaction (the backwards arrow on the neutrino just indicates that it's an anti-particle instead of a particle). So we start with a neutron, it decays into a lighter proton, the missing mass goes into producing an electron and an anti-neutrino.
 
It's worth noting that the Feynman diagram is purely symbolic. It doesn't show the geometry of a situation, or what an interaction 'looks like'. Many people seem to treat those diagrams as if they actually do.
 
  • #10
447.jpg
 
Back
Top