Would a frog be able to withstand a strong magnetic field without harm?

  • Thread starter Thread starter drag
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Powerful magnetic fields, such as those around 10 Tesla, can induce levitation in objects like frogs and spiders through a phenomenon known as diamagnetic levitation. This occurs because the magnetic repulsion acts uniformly on each atom, making the object feel as if it is in free fall. Concerns about the impact of such strong magnetic fields on the nervous system and brain functions are addressed by noting that neuroscientists use magnets of up to 7 Tesla for imaging without causing harm. The orientation of the magnetic field is crucial; stationary fields do not induce electrical interference, which is essential for maintaining neural integrity. While some magnetic therapies are marketed without scientific backing, pulsed magnets are being explored for their potential therapeutic effects on the central nervous system.
drag
Science Advisor
Messages
1,097
Reaction score
1
Greetings !

Some time ago I read about all those experiments
when they used very powerful magnetic fields
on the order of 10 Tesla (10^5 Gauss) and
above to make stuff levitate. I also
saw a picture of a levitating frog.
My question is - how come that frog stayed
alive ? Wouldn't such a powerful magnetic
field totally disrupt its entire nerveous system
and brain functions ?

Live long and prosper.
 
Biology news on Phys.org
Just a question:
How did you know it was alive ?
 
Originally posted by STAii
Just a question:
How did you know it was alive ?
It moved while being levitated and they
say it felt quite "fine" after that experience. :smile:
 
i remember seeing the same thing done with a spider. it moved around and everything while they did it
 
HM...Why do magnetic fields affect these animals? Can a strong enough magnetic field levitate anything?
 
Diamagnetic levitation.

http://www.physics.ucla.edu/marty/diamag/

Note that this magnetic replusion acts at the atomic scale. Since each atom is acted on by a nearly identical force, the frog feels like it is in free fall.
 
Originally posted by Janus
Note that this magnetic replusion acts at the atomic scale. Since each atom is acted on by a nearly identical force, the frog feels like it is in free fall.
Yes, but what about the nerve system and the
brain (based upon electrical signal exchange) ?
No damage ?

Live long and prosper.
 
neuroscientist uses up to 7Tesla imaging magnets on animals, 3T on people and that does nothing to you.

but also we can use magnets to disrupt certain areas of the brain.it's called transcranial magnetic stimulation(TMS). it's relatively new but I'm pretty sure does not use that many Teslas.

so i think that maybe the orientation of the field may matter in terms of disrupting neural activity. actually I'm pretty sure it does. in TMS you can change the orietation of the field and the effect will go away.
 
If there is no magnetic flux (either by fast movement through the magnetic field, or by rapidly altering the strength of the field), there will be no effect of electrical interferance.

In this case the magnetic field is stationary, and the frog is not moving through enough of a magnetic field gradient to cause electrical induction interference, so he is completely fine.

There are plenty of 'magnetic' therapies products on the market, those employing permanent magnets are completely ridiculous, preying on ignorance and stupidity, and if they are making any claim at all, it is a complete lie.

However, a pulsed magnet does have an effect on central nervous systems, and people are working on how to apply this in a benificial way.
 
Back
Top