Local dialect you never knew was local.

  • Thread starter Thread starter matthyaouw
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Local
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the word "tret" or "treat," which is used interchangeably with "treated" and is primarily recognized in Hull, England. Participants share their experiences of discovering localized vocabulary when traveling outside their hometowns, highlighting terms like "breadcake" (a bread roll) and "tenfoot" (an alley). The conversation expands to include various regional dialects and unique words from different areas, such as the Midwest US and Canada, illustrating how language can vary significantly even within the same country. Examples include the pronunciation of "drawer" in New Jersey and the use of "de-thaw" in the Midwest. The dialogue also touches on cultural influences on language, such as Finnish customs in South Dakota and the distinct dialects found in Ireland and Scotland. Overall, the thread emphasizes the richness of regional language variations and the humorous misunderstandings that can arise when people encounter unfamiliar terms.
matthyaouw
Gold Member
Messages
1,125
Reaction score
5
Has anyone heard the word "Tret/treat"? (Not sure how it's supposed to be spelled.)
It's used interchangably with treated, and pronounced to rhyme with 'bet'. Its a word I've always been familiar with, but was recently told that once you get more than a few miles outside of Hull no one knows what you're talking about. Its funny how you can grop up with something not realising just how localised it might be.
Also, no one outside of Hull knows what a breadcake is (a bread roll), or a tenfoot, for that matter (an alley about 10 feet wide behind a terrace of houses, built for car access).

Anyone else strayed far from home and suddenly realized no one knows what half of your vocabulary means?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
matthyaouw said:
Has anyone heard the word "Tret/treat"? (Not sure how it's supposed to be spelled.)
It's used interchangably with treated, and pronounced to rhyme with 'bet'. Its a word I've always been familiar with, but was recently told that once you get more than a few miles outside of Hull no one knows what you're talking about. Its funny how you can grop up with something not realising just how localised it might be.
Also, no one outside of Hull knows what a breadcake is (a bread roll), or a tenfoot, for that matter (an alley about 10 feet wide behind a terrace of houses, built for car access).

Anyone else strayed far from home and suddenly realized no one knows what half of your vocabulary means?
Unfortunately growing up in a large city in the US, there was no local vocabulary, although my mom was great at making up words, a tradition I have carried on, much to the distress of my girls when they found out that some of the words in their vocabulary didn't exist in the real world. :redface:
 
IMHO, large eastern US cities are full of local dialect. For example, I find people with a thick Boston accent to be quite hard to understand. Both the word pronunciation and word choice are quite different from typical American English.

Another example: When New Yorkers leave their city, they need to learn that f*** is not a good word to inject into every other sentence.
 
We had surfer and gang lingo in Los Angeles.

In the Midwest there is a funny word used to describe the action of thawing frozen food - to de-thaw - that really would imply just the opposite of "thaw". It seems that this may be a remnant of the German "be", as in "bethaw", rather than to "dethaw". Our Dutch mentor Monique once observed that as a function of a German dialect, this might make sense. The Midwest US has many people of German descent.

So much of this sort of thing could be and probably is cultural/ethnic.

There is an area in South Dakota where people used to drink their coffee with a cube of sugar held between their teeth. This was a Finnish custom, and of course the area was all Finn.
 
Last edited:
Yankees hardly ever understand what I mean when I say I'm fixin' do to something.
 
Visitors say mary-land.

We just say marrylan. No d sound.
 
cyrusabdollahi said:
Visitors say mary-land.

We just say marrylan. No d sound.

I say more like mer-i-land.

When saying "drawer," I pronounce it "draw." It's a NJ thing. It's one of the few words that are distinctly different from the way anyone else around here pronounces it...and I know because the folks in the lab are merciless about laughing over my pronunciation of that word. They say they usually can't recognize any particular accent of mine until I say that word. :rolleyes:

Oh, and I noticed a regional WV thing is to pronounce every letter in the word vehicle...they say it vee-hick'-el...accent on the middle syllable too. Most places people pronounce it with a silent H and accent on the first syllable, vee'-i-kul.
 
Last edited:
Another midwest diddy: They worsh their clothes.
 
That's nothing. I'm from one of those densely populated European regions. We have villages here where half of the locals can't understand each other for crying out loud... I'm still convinced that the dialects of West-Flanders aren't Indo-european :biggrin:

Moonbear said:
Oh, and I noticed a regional WV thing is to pronounce every letter in the word vehicle...they say it vee-hick'-el...accent on the middle syllable too. Most places people pronounce it with a silent H and accent on the first syllable, vee'-i-kul.

Sounds like Dutch-speaking influence to me...that's how we pronounce it.
 
  • #10
Umm, I don't think so :rolleyes:
 
  • #11
Matthyizzaow! Long time no smell.

I have indeed heard "tret" before, mainly in Yorkshire hospitals!

You'll love this link of an NHS document designed for healthcare professionals coming from overseas to help them understand what folk in Doncaster are on about!

http://www.doncasterwestpct.nhs.uk/uploads/reports/GlossaryforInternationalRecruits.pdf


And people look at me weird when I speak of breadcakes, but not as weird as the guys in Hull who call them 'fadges'!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
I didn't realize "gawker delays" (you know, when traffic slows down because everyone's gawking at the accident on the side of the road) was regional until I moved away from Michigan.
 
  • #13
Ivan Seeking said:
Another midwest diddy: They worsh their clothes.
:smile: I worked with a girl that spoke that way, and she pronounced "data" as "dater".
 
  • #14
Hmm... For some good examples of slang used in the south, watch Blue Collared TV.

for exampe: European

Euro-Pean on my boots.
 
  • #15
Evo said:
:smile: I worked with a girl that spoke that way, and she pronounced "data" as "dater".


Seems perfectly normal to me!
 
  • #16
matthyaouw said:
Has anyone heard the word "Tret/treat"? (Not sure how it's supposed to be spelled.)
It's used interchangably with treated, and pronounced to rhyme with 'bet'. Its a word I've always been familiar with, but was recently told that once you get more than a few miles outside of Hull no one knows what you're talking about. Its funny how you can grop up with something not realising just how localised it might be.
Also, no one outside of Hull knows what a breadcake is (a bread roll), or a tenfoot, for that matter (an alley about 10 feet wide behind a terrace of houses, built for car access).

Anyone else strayed far from home and suddenly realized no one knows what half of your vocabulary means?

As a Grimsby lad, I also say 'tret'. I've never thought about whether or not it's the standardised past conjugation of 'to treat', but now you've brought it up, it's quite interesting for a few reasons...

'Unofficial' or colloquial verb conjugations tend to gravitate toward regularity, e.g. 'catched' (colloquial) instead of 'caught' (standardised). So it's pretty weird that in North East England (and likely some other places), the past conjugation for 'to treat' veered toward irregularity. Maybe that's symptomatic of the verb 'to treat' being quite old. But I'm not very knowledgeable on the subject. Still, it's interesting to think about it :).

Do you have the verb 'to deff out' in Hull? It's synonymous with 'to worry', 'to fret' and 'to fear', but suggests that the person in the process of 'deffing out' is exhibiting physical symptoms of anxiety, such as perspiration and paling of the skin. It's associated with drug culture, e.g. somebody who starts to feel either anxious or physically sick during a Marijuana high is said to be 'deffing out'. 'To deff' (without the word 'out') tends to mean to vomit, especially while intoxicated, but can also mean 'to worry'.

It's funny about the word 'out' in the verb 'to deff out'. This is a particularly English peculiarity, which apparently poses some problems to ESOL students. Some examples: "to nip out", "to pop out", e.g. "I'm just popping out to town", meaning "I'm going to the town centre".

Could any Americans tell me if verbs with 'out' in them are used in America? Afaik, 'to pop out' is pretty universal to UK, as I've heard Londoners as well as Northerners use it. But I've never heard an American say it.
 
  • #17
brewnog said:
Matthyizzaow! Long time no smell.

I have indeed heard "tret" before, mainly in Yorkshire hospitals!

You'll love this link of an NHS document designed for healthcare professionals coming from overseas to help them understand what folk in Doncaster are on about!

http://www.doncasterwestpct.nhs.uk/uploads/reports/GlossaryforInternationalRecruits.pdf

I've been without t'internet at home for a few months, so mainly been lurking when i pop on here. Think I've read that list before.its classic :smile:

And people look at me weird when I speak of breadcakes, but not as weird as the guys in Hull who call them 'fadges'!
Even I've not heard that one...

Couperin said:
Do you have the verb 'to deff out' in Hull? It's synonymous with 'to worry', 'to fret' and 'to fear', but suggests that the person in the process of 'deffing out' is exhibiting physical symptoms of anxiety, such as perspiration and paling of the skin. It's associated with drug culture, e.g. somebody who starts to feel either anxious or physically sick during a Marijuana high is said to be 'deffing out'. 'To deff' (without the word 'out') tends to mean to vomit, especially while intoxicated, but can also mean 'to worry'.

I've heard it, but not very often, and I didn't really know what it meant. Come to think of it, it might just be my housemate from Immingham that says it. Maybe its just a south of the river thing. By the way, do you guys have tenfoots over there or is it just Hull?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #18
Dimitri Terryn said:
That's nothing. I'm from one of those densely populated European regions. We have villages here where half of the locals can't understand each other for crying out loud... I'm still convinced that the dialects of West-Flanders aren't Indo-european :biggrin:
Sounds like Dutch-speaking influence to me...that's how we pronounce it.
LOL

Dutch has a lot of influence on anglo-saxon languages. Scots (Low lands Langauge of scotland), sometimes is more like Dutch than English. Its nearest relation (after English) is friesian.

In Glasgow you will hear people saying, "I ken yer mukker, he's a braw lad." "The polis war pure metal wit ma 'cause I was mad wi it, and aye fell on mine bahoochie"

:wink:

Some people reckon that Scots should be taught in schools, and I aggree, its a pure dead gallis patter, yah ken? And there's aboot 1.5 Million in Alba wee the patter... I am aff, even some sasanaks fae the castle ken it
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Years ago, my first trip to northern Michigan. I went to someones home, and they invited me in saying..Have a seat on the Divan.
I just stood there.
 
  • #20
Cows also 'have regional accents'
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/5277090.stm
Cows have regional accents like humans, language specialists have suggested. They decided to examine the issue after dairy farmers noticed their cows had slightly different moos, depending on which herd they came from.

John Wells, Professor of Phonetics at the University of London, said regional twangs had been seen before in birds.

The farmers in Somerset who noticed the phenomenon said it may have been the result of the close bond between them and their animals.

Farmer Lloyd Green, from Glastonbury, said: "I spend a lot of time with my ones and they definitely moo with a Somerset drawl.

"I've spoken to the other farmers in the West Country group and they have noticed a similar development in their own herds.

"It works the same as with dogs - the closer a farmer's bond is with his animals, the easier it is for them to pick up his accent."

Very a-moo-sing. :biggrin:
 
  • #21
matthyaouw said:
I've heard it, but not very often, and I didn't really know what it meant. Come to think of it, it might just be my housemate from Immingham that says it. Maybe its just a south of the river thing. By the way, do you guys have tenfoots over there or is it just Hull?

They definitely say 'deff' in Immingham :smile:

Don't think I've heard 'tenfoot', unless it means the same thing as 'alley way'? Or is it related to the size of joint:-p?
 
  • #22
Couperin, we Canuks definitely use 'out' (or 'down', or 'over', or...) in the same context that you do.

The Ottawa Valley has a dialect all of its own, with UK and Maritime influences. I don't know if any of these terms are used elsewhere.

bire=barn
bairn=boy (or lad)
stook=vertically arranged sheaves of grain on the stalk (like tepees)
snake fence=a rail fence that zig-zags from one post to the next
'A' fence=a rail fence using two inward leaning posts with the rail wedged between the crossed tops
"Oh shut up!"="You're kidding?!" or "No ****?!" or similar

Those are all that I can think of right now, but there are lots more.

And here's one that I've absolutely never heard used by anyone except my mother. I have no idea where it came from.

blatherskite=someone who prattles on with no knowledge of the subject matter
 
Last edited:
  • #23
I think the unique words used in Ireland are very interesting. An Irish friend of mine that lives in the Netherlands has been giving me lessons.

From a recent letter.

"Fleadh is an interesting word because it's Irish for festival and is pronounced flah. So a fleadh ceoil is a music festival. Now fleadh ceoils were a regular thing throughout Ireland and there was great dancing, singing, music and general carousing to be had at them. In the very repressive, church dominated social system that prevailed after independence fleadhs were among the few occasions when young people of opposite sexes could actually meet in relatively unsupervised situations and behave in a somewhat reckless manner. After 3 consecutive days of such behaviour, young people would arrive home in a state of exhaustion. In Cork slang, this state became known as being fleadh'd and is normally spelt flahd or even flad. So the word fla in Cork came to mean the act of sexual intercourse. To be "flahd out" is to be exhausted. To flah something is to overwork it to the extent that it burns out or is otherwise damaged irreparably. A good looking woman, especially one in whom a man might have interests of a carnal nature became a fla. More recently I note that a good looking man has also become a fla.

In an extra twist to the use of language, when I moved to the netherlands, I discovered that it was normal on your birthday to bring cakes for your colleagues. The normal type of cake is a kind of quark/cream pie known as a Vla, which is pronounced flah! And as well as vla I always bring a tart. So for my birthday my colleagues get to have fla with tarts. Unfortunately, the attempt at humour is lost on them."
 
  • #24
Evo said:
The normal type of cake is a kind of quark/cream pie known as a Vla, which is pronounced flah!

Ah! And what color quarks do they use? What flavors are preferred?
 
  • #25
selfAdjoint said:
Ah! And what color quarks do they use? What flavors are preferred?
:biggrin: Quark is a "fromage frais".
 
  • #26
I think the unique words used in Ireland are very interesting
They are unique because those words arent English.. They are Irish Gaelic
 
  • #27
My Mother says "I swan" I think in a mannor that means I swear?
 
  • #28
Anttech said:
They are unique because those words arent English.. They are Irish Gaelic
Yes, but the Irish are REALLY bad about localized dialects. He's from Cork.
 
  • #29
Evo said:
Yes, but the Irish are REALLY bad about localized dialects. He's from Cork.

Or he's been sniffing the cork. It's hard to tell with those micks. :biggrin:
 
  • #31
Maine has some interesting peculiarities, mostly colloquialisms:

Grey Jay = gobie. In parts of Canada, they're called Whiskey-Jacks derived from a Cree word that sounded like Whiskey-John to English speakers.

"Dooryard" = front lawn and driveway

In coastal and some rural regions, "yes" is often replaced with something often written as "ayuh", but the accent is impossibly subtle, so actors (think Fred Gwynn in "Pet Semetary" and the sheriff in "Murder She Wrote") make Mainers cringe when they try it. The toughest to copy is when it is pronounced as a soft " hyuh" on an incoming breath. I have never seen this attempted in a movie or TV show.

Dynamites are meatball sandwiches served with a hot tomato sauce made with celery sweet peppers and hot peppers. The spicier the better. Generally, the meatballs are elongated and contain hamburg, ground pork, some bread, eggs, spices, and crushed red pepper.

"from away" means that the person being described is from another state.

A "flat" or a "flatlander" also an out-of-stater (lifted from the Snuffy Smith comics). "Damned flats!" is not an uncommon phrase when tourists or transplants are rude or inconsiderate.

For most of the state, if you are planning on traveling to a large town to the south, you are "goin' downriver".

"swamp donkey" = moose

"dump duck" = seagull

In the pulp and paper industry, consultants are called "seagulls" because they fly in, sh*t on you and fly out.

"flying rat" = pigeon

"sh*tpoke" = Great Blue Heron. Don't ask me why.

If someone says "go with?" they're asking if you want to accompany him/her.

"hack" or "hackmatack" = tamarack tree (deciduous conifer)

Limited usage - "hi-hosies" means something like "I called it" in the sense of children hollering "shotgun" to get the front passenger's seat in the car when a trip is suggested.

"blackgrowth" = puckerbrush = very thick stands of immature fir, hemlock, etc. Tough to get through and very difficult to hunt deer in even if you are very experienced.
 
Last edited:
  • #32
Evo said:
Yes, but the Irish are REALLY bad about localized dialects. He's from Cork.

Ok I think you are using some localised Dialect there, what do you mean? :smile:

They have a lot of dialects? I wouldn't say to an Irishman (Or a Scot for that matter) That Gaelic was a dialect :wink:

In Ireland they have dialects of English, Gaelic, and Scots. Ulster is an example of Scots.

I don't know what you would call using 2 languages beside one another..
 
  • #33
matthyaouw said:
A byre is a cow shed in Britain. Bairn means a child of either gender. Its mostly scottish but gets used in Northern England too.Learn to speak Hull: http://www.bbc.co.uk/humber/content/articles/2005/02/14/voices_hullspeak_glossary.shtml

Yeap Bairn is Scots.

http://www.scotslanguage.com/Scots/Scots_in_use/

This sense was also known to Burns, who used it in 1787 in a letter to Willie Nicol to describe two women with "as muckle smeddum and rumblegumtion as the half o' some Presbytries that you and I baith ken". Lack of pith or mettle often draws criticism, as in the following example from J. White's Moss Road (1932): "Ye poor smeddumless stock, all ye can do is to scare a bairn". Scots has an excellent hoard of terminology for everything from the smeddumfu' to the fushionless.

I think the word is seen in some robbie burns work.
 
Last edited:
  • #34
Anttech said:
In Ireland they have dialects of English, Gaelic, and Scots.
It's not correct anymore to refer to Irish as Gaelic, it's Irish. I made the mistake of referring to it as Gaelic at first. There are many local Irish dialects in Ireland.

"The language is usually referred to in English as Irish, and less often as Gaelic or Irish Gaelic. Gaelic or Irish Gaelic is often used in the Irish diaspora (also see below). Within many parts of Ireland, the choice of name has inevitably on occasion acquired political significance. Some people believe that referring to the language as "Gaelic" suggests that the language is as distant and unrelated to modern Irish life as the civilization of the ancient Gaels. Calling it Irish, on the other hand, is a more precise indication of its constitutional status as the national language of the Irish people. Irish is the term generally accepted among scholars; it is also the term used in the Republic of Ireland's Constitution.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_language

Irish Dialects

There are a number of distinct dialects of Irish. Roughly speaking, the three major dialect areas coincide with the provinces of Munster (Cúige Mumhan), Connacht (Cúige Chonnacht) and Ulster (Cúige Uladh).
 
Last edited:
  • #35
A while back I posted a link to a geordie translator which is the dialect of the region I come from (mainly Newcastle upon Tyne). Here is the link again.

http://www.geordie.org.uk/translate.htm

Its quite good but mainly gives phonetic translations. If you're familiar with newcastle brown ale you'll notice a quote on the back of the bottle in geordie of "The yen an anny", meaning the one and only. Its quite a horrible dialect and I don't like it really even though I was born here and have listened to it all my life. For those interested though I present it here.
 
  • #36
Evo said:
It's not correct anymore to refer to Irish as Gaelic, it's Irish. I made the mistake of referring to it as Gaelic at first. There are many local Irish dialects in Ireland.

Try telling that to its scottish speakers :wink:
 
  • #37
matthyaouw said:
Try telling that to its scottish speakers :wink:
They're the ones that are considered Gaelic. So you have English (most widely spoken), Irish (official language) and (Scottish) Gaelic.

I'm half English and Irish on my father's side. My maiden name is VERY Irish.
 
  • #38
Evo said:
It's not correct anymore to refer to Irish as Gaelic, it's Irish. I made the mistake of referring to it as Gaelic at first. There are many local Irish dialects in Ireland.

"The language is usually referred to in English as Irish, and less often as Gaelic or Irish Gaelic. Gaelic or Irish Gaelic is often used in the Irish diaspora (also see below). Within many parts of Ireland, the choice of name has inevitably on occasion acquired political significance. Some people believe that referring to the language as "Gaelic" suggests that the language is as distant and unrelated to modern Irish life as the civilization of the ancient Gaels. Calling it Irish, on the other hand, is a more precise indication of its constitutional status as the national language of the Irish people. Irish is the term generally accepted among scholars; it is also the term used in the Republic of Ireland's Constitution.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_language

Irish Dialects

There are a number of distinct dialects of Irish. Roughly speaking, the three major dialect areas coincide with the provinces of Munster (Cúige Mumhan), Connacht (Cúige Chonnacht) and Ulster (Cúige Uladh).


I didnt call anything "Irish"... Ulster is actually a dialect of scots, and it is NOT a dialect of English or "Irish" or gaelic. I suppose by "Irish" you mean Irish dialects of English?
 
  • #39
Anttech said:
I didnt call anything "Irish"... Ulster is actually a dialect of scots, and it is NOT a dialect of English or "Irish" or gaelic. I suppose by "Irish" you mean Irish dialects of English?
No, "Irish" is a language, it is the OFFICIAL language of Ireland.
 
  • #40
Evo said:
They're the ones that are considered Gaelic. So you have English (most widely spoken), Irish (official language) and (Scottish) Gaelic.

Gaelic of Ireland and the Highlands of Scotland are not the same thing. They are similar but not the same thing.

Nor is the Irish version of Gaelic called Irish.

In Ireland they have 3 languages spoken. Scots (NOT Gaelic) Gaelic, and English, the same as Scotland.
 
  • #41
Evo said:
No, "Irish" is a language, it is the OFFICIAL language of Ireland.

:rolleyes:

Ireland is an English name for Eire, Irish is also the English way to say someone from ireland. Why would Gaelic be called by an English name, when it isn't even from the same language group? It is from the Celtic Group..
 
  • #42
Anttech said:
:rolleyes:

Ireland is an English name for Eire, Irish is also the English way to say someone from ireland. Why would Gaelic be called by an English name, when it isn't even from the same language group? It is from the Celtic Group..
Wow, you really don't know that Irish is a language? SHAME ON YOU! You may apologize now.

http://foreignaffairs.gov.ie/Press_Releases/20050613/1774.htm

Minister Dermot Ahern announces Official and Working Status for the Irish language in EU: Government Proposal Unanimously Accepted By EU Foreign Ministers

The Minister for Foreign Affairs, Mr. Dermot Ahern T.D., has welcomed today's decision by EU Foreign Ministers unanimously to approve the Irish Government's proposal to accord official and working status in the EU to the Irish language.

I am very pleased that the Irish language has been accorded official and working status in the European Union. This affirms at European level the dignity and status of our first official language. This represents a particularly significant practical step for the Irish language, and complements the Government's wider policy of strong support for the language at home. I am grateful to our EU partners for their agreement to the Government's proposal,” said Minister Ahern.

The proposal results in a major enhancement of the status of the Irish language in the EU. It becomes the twenty-first official and working language of the Union.

http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/translation/spotlight/irish_en.htm

Irish becomes the 21st official language of the EU
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #43
I think I know what you are getting wrong. You are translating the name Gaelic into English, and saying its Irish. That is debatable considering that many Highlanders in Scotland speak it. The Name of the Langauge is Gaelic or Gaeilic Depending on how you spell it.
 
  • #44
Anttech said:
I think I know what you are getting wrong. You are translating the name Gaelic into English, and saying its Irish. That is debatable considering that many Highlanders in Scotland speak it. The Name of the Langauge is Gaelic or Gaeilic Depending on how you spell it.
:smile: OH MY GOD! Have you been living under a rock?

Have you read what I posted?

IRISH IS THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF IRELAND. In Irish it's spelled Ghaeilge. But to make the differentiation, Irish is no longer considered Gaelic, that's why they pushed for the differentiation. The wiki article is a pretty easy explanation, I suggest you read it.
 
Last edited:
  • #45
Wow, you really don't know that Irish is a language? SHAME ON YOU! You may apologize now.
Irish is Gaelic... Go read your link, shame on you, and you are trying to show your "Irish" heritage, and you didnt even know that :wink:

Heres a few others for you:

http://www.unhchr.ch/udhr/lang/gli1.htm

Irish Gaelic, often known simply as Irish, is an official language of the Republic of Ireland. It belongs to the Indo-European family, Celtic group,

http://www.englishirishdictionary.com/

Its even on the translator. It is GAELIC... Or Irish Gaelic

H MY GOD! Have you been living under a rock?

Have you read what I posted?

IRISH IS THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF IRELAND.

GEEZE O PETE, ARE YOU BLIND?

No.. It seems you are.. The word IRISH isn't even Gaelic so why would they call their language Irish? And to top that, I DOUBT any GAELIC speakers in Scotland would be telling anyone they speak Irish, because they dont.. They speak Gaelic...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #46
matthyaouw said:
Try telling that to its scottish speakers :wink:

Exactly. I am being taught how to suck eggs here it seems. I was born and lived most of my life in Glasgow :rolleyes:
 
  • #47
Not anymore, read the article. They want to separate Irish from being referred to as Gaelic.

We are speaking English on here, we say Irish for the Irish language, French for the French language, German for the German language. Why would I say Ghaeilge for Irish? I wouldn't say Deutsch for German, or Francais for French.

You specifically mis-stated that there is no such thing as an Irish language. You're wrong. Did you see the prolamation where Irish is now the 21st official language in the EU?

Anttech said:
Exactly. I am being taught how to suck eggs here it seems. I was born and lived most of my life in Glasgow :rolleyes:
And apparently haven't read a newspaper in two years. :wink:
 
Last edited:
  • #48
Not anymore, read the article. They want to separate Irish from being referred to as Gaelic.
I read it thanks, but it is still Gaelic, it didnt just stop being Gaelic, because the Irish decided to call Gaelic Irish (Rather than Erse (sp?)), and it is so close to Highland Gaelic that it is insulting to call it Irish to a 1000's generation Scotsman, who has spoken gaelic all his life, just because the Irish have decided to call gaelic 'Irish"

And apparently haven't read a newspaper in two years.

Nope I am very interested in my local Languages, I have a colourful background, and this makes me very interested in these things. I also have local knowledge, and without me knowing it I discovered I can speak 2 languages English and Scots. We have a Fair amount of Gaelic on the TV now also, and culture and history programs... Nothing really like local knowledge for these things now is there?
 
  • #49
Anttech said:
I read it thanks, but it is still Gaelic, it didnt just stop being Gaelic, because the Irish decided to call Gaelic Irish (Rather than Erse (sp?)), and it is so close to Highland Gaelic that it is insulting to call it Irish to a 1000's generation Scotsman, who has spoken gaelic all his life, just because the Irish have decided to call gaelic 'Irish"
Well, they made it a legal change, I had nothing to do with it. :smile: And my Irish friend is teaching me Irish. He also calls it Irish. Besides, no one can understand the Scots. :wink: I used to date one.
 
  • #50
LMAO:

So I must be an "Irish Denier" then.. Hope they don't lock me up :rolleyes:

As for scots, its supposed to be like that ;)
 
Back
Top