News Looking for an Introduction to American Politics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter QueenFisher
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    System
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on recommendations for introductory books on American politics, emphasizing the importance of foundational texts like the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Federalist Papers. These documents are viewed as essential for understanding the intended structure and ideals of the U.S. political system. However, participants express skepticism about their relevance to contemporary politics, noting that the founding documents reflect the views of a limited demographic—primarily white men—and do not address the complexities of modern issues such as civil rights and government scandals. The conversation highlights the need for a nuanced understanding of American political history, acknowledging both the ideals set forth by the founders and the realities of historical injustices and ongoing political challenges. Alexis de Tocqueville's "Democracy in America" is recommended for its critical insights into American political culture, though it is noted that it presents a specific viewpoint rather than an objective analysis. Overall, the dialogue underscores the tension between historical ideals and current political realities.
QueenFisher
i read a book recently that was based on politics in america (a fiction book), and i wondered if anyone knows of any good sort of general introductory books an american politics? like, the election system, congress, the senate, that kind of thing.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Alexis de Toqueville's Democracy in America
 
After you read the founding papers and how the American system is supposed to work, I'll be glad to refer you to reading on how the system really is now.
 
SOS2008 said:
After you read the founding papers and how the American system is supposed to work, I'll be glad to refer you to reading on how the system really is now.
You got to start out with the fairy-tale version of America, otherwise, how are you supposed to understand what everyone's supposedly striving for?

Though, of course, the current U.S. government and population has different ideals than did those who set it up in the late 1700's. But then, even George Washington's administration was accused of violating the Constitution and abandoning American ideals.

One of the main things about our founding documents, however, is that they're made to be flexible, and made to be ambiguous. Our Founders knew there'd be lots of changes in the future, and set up the U.S.A. so that it would be flexible and able to grow into whatever it needed to be.

But besides all that ideological crap, there's also plain illegal and immoral stuff going on, just as there is in any government.
 
Well, the founding documents were all by, and about, white men. Nothing about their wives, slaves, the native americans who were in their expansionist way, etc.

We've had a Civil War, Women's Lib, and are currently in a scandal involving a lobbyist for some of the tribes. None of this could be deduced from the founding documents, and the idea that reading them will greatly inform anyone about how politics works today is just silly, or idealistic. And the idea that we SHOULD behave the way Madison dreamed we might (absent all those ignored people) in the agrarian pre-industrial world he lived in is even worse!
 
I'd rather live according to Madison than Madison Avenue.
 
selfAdjoint said:
Well, the founding documents were all by, and about, white men. Nothing about their wives, slaves, the native americans who were in their expansionist way, etc.

We've had a Civil War, Women's Lib, and are currently in a scandal involving a lobbyist for some of the tribes. None of this could be deduced from the founding documents, and the idea that reading them will greatly inform anyone about how politics works today is just silly, or idealistic. And the idea that we SHOULD behave the way Madison dreamed we might (absent all those ignored people) in the agrarian pre-industrial world he lived in is even worse!
True. At the current time I am most concerned about checks and balances as it applies to protection of civil liberties and minority rights:

Constitutionalism is the idea, often associated with the political theories of John Locke and the "founders" of the American republic, and equated with the concept of the "Rule of Law", that government can and should be legally limited in its powers, and that its authority depends on enforcing these limitations.
http://www.constitution.org/constitutionalism.htm
 
  • #10
WarrenPlatts said:
Alexis de Toqueville's Democracy in America
Ditto on Toqueville. But don't expect an objective description though, it presents a specific viewpoint, that of a 'progressive aristocrat' from the age of emerging (classical) liberalism. This is valuable though because he really raises a lot of questions and thoughts on the US political system and culture.

Tocqueville was one of the first European Academics to take the US seriously. He had some great insights.
 
  • #11
QueenFisher said:
i read a book recently that was based on politics in america (a fiction book), and i wondered if anyone knows of any good sort of general introductory books an american politics? like, the election system, congress, the senate, that kind of thing.

You might try Wikipedia.
 
  • #12
selfAdjoint said:
Well, the founding documents were all by, and about, white men. Nothing about their wives, slaves, the native americans who were in their expansionist way, etc.

We've had a Civil War, Women's Lib, and are currently in a scandal involving a lobbyist for some of the tribes. None of this could be deduced from the founding documents, and the idea that reading them will greatly inform anyone about how politics works today is just silly, or idealistic. And the idea that we SHOULD behave the way Madison dreamed we might (absent all those ignored people) in the agrarian pre-industrial world he lived in is even worse!
Well, there was something about slaves. 3/5 comprimise, and the thing about no new slaves being imported after 1810 or something.

And of course it's different today than it was then, but those are still the basis of American history, whether you like it or not, whether they were fair/good/proper/racist/evil, they are the basis of everything.
 

Similar threads

Replies
42
Views
1K
Replies
74
Views
10K
Replies
51
Views
8K
Replies
129
Views
20K
Replies
3
Views
591
Back
Top