Macroscopic field - seeking a thorough exposition

12 replies · 2K views · last reply
coquelicot
Messages
304
Reaction score
70
TL;DR
I'm seeking a thorough exposition of the definition of the macroscopic EM field
Of the classical books about EM, I found that Jackson's is the only one that touches with some rigour the subject of deriving the macroscopic field from the microscopic one.
Unfortunately, I am quite disappointed by the derivation of Jackson.
In the reference he gives, he says that a couple of authors have spent their lives about this subject, but I was unable to find their book.

Do you know a rigorous and thorough exposition of this matter? I am not looking for a vague "diagrammatic" persuasion, but something closer to the state of the art on this subject.
 
coquelicot said:
TL;DR Summary: I'm seeking a thorough exposition of the definition of the macroscopic EM field

Of the classical books about EM, I found that Jackson's is the only one that touches with some rigour the subject of deriving the macroscopic field from the microscopic one.
Unfortunately, I am quite disappointed by the derivation of Jackson.
In the reference he gives, he says that a couple of authors have spent their lives about this subject, but I was unable to find their book.

Do you know a rigorous and thorough exposition of this matter? I am not looking for a vague "diagrammatic" persuasion, but something closer to the state of the art on this subject.
Maybe this, but it's in German:
https://static.uni-graz.at/fileadmi.../mitter_heinrich/Dokumente/Elektrodynamik.pdf

From p. 126 and 163
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and coquelicot
Yes, German is a problem for me, but I had a look at the formulae; that seems rather descriptive. I am in doubt this is a thorough exposition of the matter.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Philip Koeck
These might be of interest
Macroscopic Electromagnetism by Robinson
Electrodynamics of Continuous Media by Landau
A Development of the Equations of Electromagnetism in Material Continua by Tiersten
Electrodynamics of Continua by Eringen and Maugin
Electrodynamics of Moving Media by Penfield and Haus
The Maxwell Equations by de Groot
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and coquelicot
None of these are “standard” EM books. They are all focused on continuous media.
I would guess that de Groot and Robinson would be of most interest to you. I believe that there are additional de Groot references that I do not have handy.
 
OK thx. I've already read Landau, and no, it does not contain the deal.
 
I would check out Ch. 3 of Wald's book on electromagnetism. He gives a very nice derivation.
 
Here's the preface from de Groot
Scanned printed page of text, the preface of a book on the macroscopic electromagnetic theory of matter, discussing Lorentz's derivation of Maxwell's equations from microscopic electron theory and the chapter-by-chapter outline that follows.
 
Last edited:
Here's the preface from Robinson
Scanned printed page titled Preface, a dense block of text about electromagnetism texts discussing macroscopic electromagnetism, the B, H, E and D vectors, and SI units, with page number xi at the bottom.Scanned printed page headed Preface, showing dense body text on electromagnetism, macroscopic fields, and the Maxwell equations written in vector notation, with a page number xii at the bottom.Scanned printed page titled Preface, dense justified body text about macroscopic electromagnetism, the microscopic atomic structure of matter and chapter outline, numbered xiii at the bottom.Scanned printed page titled Preface, a text-only page of prose discussing the use of mathematical argument versus physical intuition in a book on electromagnetism, with an acknowledgement paragraph at the bottom.
 
Last edited:
Nice ! Robinson seems to be my man, as he writes exactly what I thought in his preface. Groot may be in contradiction with Robinson, that is, he may derive things in the classical erroneous way. But I don't know I have to read to have an opinion.