Mass of a galaxy without dark matter and with dark matter

  • Thread starter Quarlep
  • Start date
257
4
I am curious about mass of a galaxy without dark matter and with dark matter.I searched but I couldnt found.I ll be happy If you help me.

Thanks
 
15,077
4,721
Well, without dark matter there most likely would not BE any galaxy. although DM does not "clump" the way normal matter does, it has somehow accumulated into cosmologically massive blobs that then attract regular matter through gravitational attraction and the regular matter clumps into stars and planets and dust and the whole mess is a galaxy.

So asking what a galaxy would be like without the dark matter is a bit like asking how well someone could sing if they had no vocal chords.
 
257
4
Without dark matter I mean without dark matter mass my fault I forget mass
 
32,826
8,670
Without dark matter I mean without dark matter mass my fault I forget mass
How does that change the question?

For an existing galaxy, you can ask how much visible and how much invisible mass there are. The answer depends on the galaxy and the radius you consider (galaxies do not have sharp edges, especially in the dark matter distribution), but there are many galaxies where numbers are available online.
 

wabbit

Gold Member
1,284
207
I think the ratio of dark matter to matter is about the same in a typical galaxy (DM halo included) as the overall ratio of 85:15 but I could very well be wrong.
 
15,077
4,721
I think the ratio of dark matter to matter is about the same in a typical galaxy (DM halo included) as the overall ratio of 85:15 but I could very well be wrong.
The rabbit ? WRONG ? Not very likely :smile:
 

wabbit

Gold Member
1,284
207
Don't joke about the poor rabbit :) he's still recovering from almost loosing his legs in a black hole:smile:
 
257
4
Is that right isnt it 85/15
 

Vanadium 50

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
22,849
5,097
I think the ratio of dark matter to matter is about the same in a typical galaxy
There exist both DM-rich and DM-poor galaxies.
 
15,077
4,721
Don't joke about the poor rabbit :) he's still recovering from almost loosing his legs in a black hole:smile:
I TOLD you to stay away from those things !
 

wabbit

Gold Member
1,284
207
Yes mom, I won't do it again, promise:)
 

wabbit

Gold Member
1,284
207
There exist both DM-rich and DM-poor galaxies.
I was wondering about that, or something related rather - in galaxy collisions the matter tends to coalesce into a single galaxy after a while due I believe to some kind of friction - but with high enough collision velocity it seems that (some part of) the dark matter halos could just move through each other and continue on their way. If that does happen, not only would we be left with a DM poor merged galaxy, but also with stray haloes of dark matter zooming away without much matter left in them . Is that something that happens and if so do we see such stray halos (through lensing or other means)?
 
32,826
8,670
Well, there are objects like the bullet cluster where the distribution of dark matter differs significantly from the distribution of gas.
Stars also don't have much friction, so a complete separation of visible and dark matter would be odd.
 

wabbit

Gold Member
1,284
207
Thanks, I thought "some kind of friction" arising from matter-matter interaction (gas clouds maybe?) played a role in the merger process - but you re saying it's minor and essentially gravitational effects alone explain the process, did I get that right?

And yes I was thinking of the bullet cluster - though I don't recall seeing mention of stray halos escaping in that case, so I was freely extrapolating - perhaps a little too far : )
 
15,077
4,721
Thanks, I thought "some kind of friction" arising from matter-matter interaction (gas clouds maybe?) played a role in the merger process - but you re saying it's minor and essentially gravitational effects alone explain the process, did I get that right?
Actually, I think the dust interactions DO contribute an effect, it's just that stars/planets are so far apart that THEY don't hit each other.
 
257
4
do you not understand that 85:15 IS 85/15 or are you making a joke?
Yeah I understand it like that
Its not 85/15 then what it is.
 
257
4
I was watching House and there House said dark matter makes galaxies 6 times bigger mass.And I am curious about is that same for every galaxy ? Example a galaxy mass is m without dark matter.But with dark matter 6m.Is that true for all galaxies ? (85/15 near to 6 so I made a connection)
 
15,077
4,721
I was watching House and there House said dark matter makes galaxies 6 times bigger mass.And I am curious about is that same for every galaxy ? Example a galaxy mass is m without dark matter.But with dark matter 6m.Is that true for all galaxies ? (85/15 near to 6 so I made a connection)
Which part of post #10 did you not understand?
 
257
4
There exist both DM-rich and DM-poor galaxies.
So DM does not depend mass of galaxy.But this sound like stupid I guess.In quote I guess he means mass depend DM which less mass galaxies have Poor DM and heavier galaxies have Rich Dm
 

Chronos

Science Advisor
Gold Member
11,398
733
The whole DM issue is confusing. Some galaxies appear to be rich in it, and others largely lacking. That suggests we may be missing an important clue.
 
257
4
I understand.Do you have any internet resources for that.This extra mass idea or DM rich DM poor stuff
 

Vanadium 50

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
22,849
5,097
But this sound like stupid I guess
If you don't like what I said, provide a counterexample or counterargument, or at least ask a question. Don't just call it stupid. It's not just unhelpful. It's rude.

If you bothered to type "dark matter rich galaxies" in Google, you would have gotten 70,600 hits. If I were you, I'd do a bit more research before telling other people that they are wrong.
 

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top