Engineering Measuring rotational speed for Tachometer vs Oscilloscope

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the discrepancy between rotational speed readings from a tachometer and an oscilloscope, with the tachometer showing 1930 RPM and the oscilloscope indicating 3857.91 RPM due to it detecting two pulses per rotation. Participants suggest that the oscilloscope may be misinterpreting the signal from a Hall effect sensor, which outputs two pulses for each complete rotation of the motor. Recommendations include adjusting the oscilloscope's gain settings to align the readings more closely with the tachometer. Additionally, there is a need for clarity on the type of motor and tachometer used, as well as the experimental setup. Accurate measurement of the signal period is advised to resolve the frequency discrepancy.
Special One
Messages
32
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
f = 64.3 [Hz]
w = 1930 [RPM]
Relevant Equations
w=2*pi*f
Question: Why does the oscilloscope double almost the exact value of rotational speed measured by Tachometer?

Rotational speed from Tachometer = 1930 [RPM]
Frequency of 1 period = 64.3 [Hz] which means 3857.91 [RPM]

The output waveform of hall-effect sensor is attached.
Can you have any explanation please?
 

Attachments

  • 6.PNG
    6.PNG
    9.2 KB · Views: 143
Physics news on Phys.org
We need a link to the experimental setup.

A magnet has two poles, but it appears the oscilloscope is seeing only one polarity, so that should be OK. What is the hall effect sensor sensing? How is the magnet mounted?

What type of tachometer are you using?
Maybe it is locking to a harmonic of the rotation.

What type of motor is it?
At 65 Hz, it is probably not an AC induction motor.
The distributor of a 4 stroke motor, where there might be a Hall effect sensor, rotates at half the speed of the crankshaft.
 
Baluncore said:
We need a link to the experimental setup.

A magnet has two poles, but it appears the oscilloscope is seeing only one polarity, so that should be OK. What is the hall effect sensor sensing? How is the magnet mounted?

What type of tachometer are you using?
Maybe it is locking to a harmonic of the rotation.

What type of motor is it?
At 65 Hz, it is probably not an AC induction motor.
The distributor of a 4 stroke motor, where there might be a Hall effect sensor, rotates at half the speed of the crankshaft.
The answer is because it puts out 2 pulses for every rotation.
So, in order fix this problem we should change the gain in oscilloscope from
+60.000,000 to +30.000,000
Now we will be getting the exact value as it is in the tachometer.
 
Special One said:
The answer is because it puts out 2 pulses for every rotation.
What is "it", and why does it "put out" two pulses per rotation ?

Special One said:
So, in order fix this problem we should change the gain in oscilloscope from
+60.000,000 to +30.000,000
The gain of an oscilloscope sets the vertical scale, not the sweep rate.

I would not assume that the two pulses per rev are equally spaced. So you should measure the period of two cycles of the signal with the oscilloscope, then take the reciprocal to convert that to frequency.
 
Greetings to all, I am writing with a question regarding graph generation in LTSpice. I am using LTSpice XVII and am trying to plot AM-AM and AM-PM characterization for a power amplifier, but I haven't been successful yet, likely due to my lack of practice with this specific analysis. I have been using a square wave input at 8.2 MHz as the voltage waveform for my power amplifier. It is said that for a switching amplifier like Class-D, the AM-AM / AM-PM (amplitude-to-amplitude and...
Thread 'How do I determine the resistance for RLC low pass filter?'
Hi, I am trying to build a RLC low pass filter that atenuates the frequency below 4500 Hz. However, I have encountered some problem when choosing the correct R to work with. Here is the Circuit Here is the original sound. Here is my code in Matlab function Vout = myFilterCircuit(Vin,h) n_V = length(Vin); f_7 = 4470;; % Undesired frequency h_7 = h; % delta time % These are for the constant and initialization of the variables t_7 = 0:h_7:(n_V-1)*h_7; % This is the independent variable...