Mr/s Knowledgable - Possibility of All-Round Knowledge?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lisa!
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the distinction between trivia and knowledge, emphasizing that trivia consists of isolated facts without deeper understanding, while knowledge involves comprehension and the ability to apply information meaningfully. Participants reflect on the nature of learning, suggesting that true knowledge is acquired through experience, critical thinking, and the willingness to acknowledge one's limitations. The conversation also touches on the tendency of some individuals to express strong opinions on topics they lack firsthand experience in, highlighting the importance of informed discourse. Overall, the dialogue underscores the value of thoughtful engagement and the continuous pursuit of knowledge over mere memorization of facts.
Lisa!
Gold Member
Messages
650
Reaction score
99
Is it possible to be so knowledgeable about all sorts of things? :rolleyes:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you watched Jeopardy?
 
What do you mean?
 
TheStatutoryApe said:
Have you watched Jeopardy?
That's trivia. Trivia is, by definition, not knowledge.
 
"He's a genius. A real genius... Why, Oppenheimer knows about everything. He can talk to you about anything you bring up. Well, not exactly. I guess there are a few things he doesn't know about. He doesn't know anything about sports."
 
Smurf said:
That's trivia. Trivia is, by definition, not knowledge.

I agree. I remember almost none of the facts I learned through school or uni, what I took away was ways of thinking, making deductions and conclusions. Trivia just reflects your memory.
 
What's the difference between trivia and knowledge? Trivia is useless and knowledge is useful?
 
Lisa! said:
Is it possible to be so knowledgeable about all sorts of things? :rolleyes:
Yes it is. Why do you ask?
 
knowledge implies understanding. Trivia is just facts.

For example, most people know who came up with e=mc^2, but have little or no knowledge of how it was derived.

Dictionary.com:

knowledge

1 a : awareness or understanding esp. of an act, a fact, or the truth
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Some people will profess to know more then they do, while others really do know a lot.
I find that the ones who really know a lot, are more likely to tell you when they don't know something.
 
  • #11
Astronuc said:
Yes it is.

How?



Why do you ask?
I'll tell you later. :smile:
 
  • #12
Lisa! said:
How?

Use one's senses - sight, smell, feel (touch), hear/listen, taste.

Read, think, contemplate, introspect, meditate. Understand. Question. Hypothesize. Theorize. Test.

Learn.

Know when one is wrong.

Make mistakes. Correct mistakes.

How many things? Two, three, five, 10, a dozen.

Acquisition of knowledge takes time.
 
  • #13
Astronuc said:
Use one's senses - sight, smell, feel (touch), hear/listen, taste.

Read, think, contemplate, introspect, meditate. Understand. Question. Hypothesize. Theorize. Test.

Learn.

Know when one is wrong.

Make mistakes. Correct mistakes.

How many things? Two, three, five, 10, a dozen.

Acquisition of knowledge takes time.
How poetic. And great advice too. :approve:
I once read someone describe Shakespeare as 'a man on whom nothing was lost'. It was the first time that I heard the phrase, and it's been one of my favorites ever since. Be a (hu)man on whom nothing is lost. :smile:
 
  • #14
Astronuc said:
Use one's senses - sight, smell, feel (touch), hear/listen, taste.

Read, think, contemplate, introspect, meditate. Understand. Question. Hypothesize. Theorize. Test.

Learn.

Know when one is wrong.

Make mistakes. Correct mistakes.

How many things? Two, three, five, 10, a dozen.

Acquisition of knowledge takes time.
Your suggestions are always useful. :smile:


why do you ask?
I see some people who jump into any discussion and some of them are really opinionated about what they say.For sure we can't be master in everything , but they think they are!Well you knw sometimes they commont on things that they have no experience about them.For example they commont on other countries' people.Although they never travel to that country, meet any person from that country or read any book or even watchany movie from that country! :bugeye:
 
  • #15
Lisa! said:
I see some people who jump into any discussion and some of them are really opinionated about what they say.For sure we can't be master in everything , but they think they are!Well you knw sometimes they commont on things that they have no experience about them.For example they commont on other countries' people.Although they never travel to that country, meet any person from that country or read any book or even watchany movie from that country! :bugeye:
I see your point.

Yes, the phenomenon is called "freedom of expression". One is free to say whatever one wishes, as long as if conforms to guidelines and rules to which one agrees as part of accepting membership in PF. One can believe anything, rightly or wrongly, but it is a matter of belief or opinion. Hopefully those expressing opinions are well-informed, but sometimes that does not appear to be so.

One is also free to disagree and to express disagreement.

It would be nice if everyone were skilled in the art of disputation and rhetoric. Alas, in the modern world, this seems a lost art. :frown:
 

Similar threads

Back
Top