Muon Decay: Special Relativity WS#1 Homework

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a homework problem involving muon decay and special relativity. The muon, created at 60 km altitude and traveling at 0.998 times the speed of light, has an internal clock that registers 2.0 microseconds before it decays. The first part of the problem asks for the distance the muon would travel if time were absolute, while the second part incorporates time dilation effects from special relativity. The confusion stems from understanding how to apply the concept of time dilation in calculations, particularly distinguishing between the muon's internal clock and the ground observer's clock. Participants emphasize the importance of recognizing that the muon decays based on its own time frame, not that of the Earth observer.
relativelnr00
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


[/B]
1.) A muon is created by a cosmic ray interaction at an altitude of 60km. Imagine that after its creation, the muon hurtles downward at a speed of 0.998, as measure by a ground-based observer. After the muon’s “internal clock” registers 2.0μs , the muon decays?

a.) If the muon’s internal clock were to measure the same time between its birth and death as clock on the ground do (i.e. if special relativity is not true and time is absolute), about how far would this muon have traveled before it decayed?

b.) How far will this muon really travel before it decays?

Homework Equations


300m = 300m(1s/3x10^8m) = 10^-6s = 1μs
∆Sab = √∆t^2ab - ∆x^2ab (?)

The Attempt at a Solution


60km = 200μs

a) If time is absolute:

Muon decays at 600m, or 2μs away from the starting point of 60km, or 200μs (?)

b) 300m = 1μs , thus 2μs = 600m
600m/0.998 = 601.2 m (?)

Anyone have any advice? I'm not looking for the whole solution to be given to me, but I'm at a standstill in terms of my understanding of how the problem works...
 

Attachments

  • upload_2015-2-25_22-27-34.png
    upload_2015-2-25_22-27-34.png
    100 bytes · Views: 505
  • upload_2015-2-25_22-34-34.png
    upload_2015-2-25_22-34-34.png
    100 bytes · Views: 478
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you know what time dilation is?
 
Orodruin said:
Do you know what time dilation is?

I only recently learned what time dilation is, so I'm still very unfamiliar with how the concept works within the math aspect of special relativity. What confuses me most is that the first part of this problem asks for an absolute time version, while the second part asks for something different...
 
The first question asks you what would happen if there was not time dilation due to special relativity, so of course it will be different.

The second question asks you what happens when special relativity holds, i.e., when there is time dilation. Note that the muon will only decay when 2 microseconds have passed according to its "clock", not the clock in the Earth rest frame.
 
Orodruin said:
The first question asks you what would happen if there was not time dilation due to special relativity, so of course it will be different.

The second question asks you what happens when special relativity holds, i.e., when there is time dilation. Note that the muon will only decay when 2 microseconds have passed according to its "clock", not the clock in the Earth rest frame.
I'm still unsure about how to approach the first part of the problem, but with the second part:

The muon decays when two microseconds have passed by its clock. It's traveling downwards at a speed of .998, so almost the speed of light. Thus:
2 microseconds = 600 meters
600m/0.998 = 601.2 m

In this case, I'm assuming that dividing by the speed will give me the actual distance that the muon has traveled. Yet something still feels off to me.

Alternatively, should I attempt to plugin the values into the formula ∆Sab = √∆t^2ab - ∆x^2ab?
 
No, you are computing it with the time elapsed on an Earth clock. This is not what the question asks for. The muon survives until 2 microseconds has passed in its own rest frame.
 
Orodruin said:
No, you are computing it with the time elapsed on an Earth clock. This is not what the question asks for. The muon survives until 2 microseconds has passed in its own rest frame.
Orodruin,

I assume then that I just solved for problem a), which assumes that the muon's clock measures the same as one on the ground.

As for problem b, I have no clue where to start. I feel like I may be missing a formula or equation, or maybe it's one I have not learned yet.

I do appreciate the assistance, I'm just not sure where to go next within this problem.
 
relativelnr00 said:
I only recently learned what time dilation is

I suggest reviewing that part of your course literature.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top