My tutor set me out to figure out how shadows are 3D.I'm 14 so I

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding the 3D nature of shadows, sparked by a tutor's challenge. Participants explore the concept that while a shadow on a surface is 2D, the area where light is blocked is 3D, referencing the space between objects. They also touch on the Earth's shadow during an eclipse, discussing the shapes of umbra and penumbra, and the cone shape of the umbra. Additionally, a participant raises a separate question about the relationship between time and space, particularly in relation to orbits. The conversation highlights the complexity of these concepts and encourages further exploration.
Cbray
Messages
130
Reaction score
0
My tutor set me out to figure out how shadows are 3D.
I'm 14 so I said they can't because shadows don't have depth.
How is this possible? He said I won't fully understand until year 12.

If you know anything please post,
thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org


I think i got what he meant. Think about the space between you and the shadow you project on a wall, for example. Is this space at light or at shadow? Is this space 2D or 3D?
 


This is kind of a confusing question. Your actual shadow that is projected onto a surface is 2d, but the area that light is being blocked from is 3d. Could you tell what context this was in? What were you guys studying exactly?
 
Hi Cbray! :smile:

Hint: the Moon is eclipsed when it enters the Earth's shadow …

what shape is the Earth's shadow? :wink:
 


Umbra and Penumbra..?
Haha I have no clue, tell me :>
 
And what shape is the umbra? :wink:
 


A cone?
 
Yup! :smile:

And how many dimensions is a cone? :wink:
 


So are you just saying that the space between the two objects is technically a 3D shadow?
 
  • #10


Tiny-Tim I got another question (I'm 14 and want to become an astrophysicist).

Q) How can time be apart of the universe/space, since it's just a measurement. If we were in a further or closer orbit, wouldn't our time measurement be different? And what if we weren't in orbit, we wouldn't have time then.. or would we?
 
  • #11
What two objects? :confused:
 
  • #12


The Earth and Moon.
I was just referring to anything in real life, but obviously the shape would be different.

Can you read my question, please?
 
  • #13
A shadow belongs to only one object. :wink:
 
  • #14


Sorry I must of typed it wrong to confuse you.. :L
Can you answer my question, it's been stuck in my head forever.
 
  • #15
Cbray said:
Can you read my question, please?

That's a completely different question …

please start a new thread. :smile:
 

Similar threads

Back
Top