I Noether's theorem for discrete symmetry

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the existence of a discrete version of Noether's theorem for potentials with discrete symmetry, such as $C_n$. Participants express skepticism about applying Noether's theorem, which is rooted in continuous symmetries, to discrete cases, suggesting that key elements may not translate effectively. The conversation highlights the importance of conservation laws in Hamiltonian mechanics and the potential for finding invariant quantities along trajectories, even in chaotic systems. Lattice theory and lattice gauge theory are mentioned as possible avenues for further exploration of these concepts. Ultimately, the focus remains on understanding symmetries and constants of motion within the framework of Hamiltonian mechanics.
Dalor
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
I am wondering if it existes some discret version of the Noether symmetry for potential with discrete symmetry (like $C_n$ ).

The purpose is to describe the possible evolution of the phase space over the time without having to solve equations numerically (since even if the potential may have some symmetry solving the equation may be long and exhibe some chaotic behavior).

Thank's
 
Physics news on Phys.org
So no one has any insight for that ? Even a small one ?
 
Dalor said:
So no one has any insight for that ? Even a small one ?
No, I am not sure about it, but I cannot imagine it. Noether's theorem is a result of a variation process, continuously changing differential coordinates. It is a statement about Lie groups, i.e. analytical groups - originally called continuous groups. So major ingredients simply break away in any discrete case. Maybe one can consider different connection components or coverings to map discrete behavior, but that's more a guess than an insight.
 
Thank you for the answer, yes I came to the same conclusion it does not seems easy to go from continuous to discret case. And may be Noether Theorem is not the correct approach.

But I said Noether Theorem at first because I am interesting in concervation law in my Hamiltonian.

Maybe there is other "easy" way to find invariant quantity along the trajectory in hamiltonian mechanic ? (This is for classical case not quantum one).
And by considering symmetry we could maybe conclude some interesting things on the solution even if the full solution is not found.

I am interesting in this because even if I know that the solution exhib chaotic solution it does not mean than the full phase space is reachable from any initial condition.
 
To me this discussion is the clearest in Hamiltonian mechanics. A constant of motion is some function ##S(q,p)## of your generalised coordinates that satisfies ##\dot S = 0##. From the equations of motion, this derivative is given by ##\dot S = \{S,H\}## and therefore ##\{S,H\} = 0## for a constant of motion. Due to the anti-symmetry of the Poisson bracket, this also means that ##\{H,S\} = 0##, which means that ##H## does not change under the canonical transformations generated by ##S##, i.e., those canonical transformations are a one-parameter set of transformations that are a symmetry of the Hamiltonian. In other words, you can go both ways, continuous symmetry ⇔ constant of motion.
 
Thread 'Is there a white hole inside every black hole?'
This is what I am thinking. How much feasible is it? There is a white hole inside every black hole The white hole spits mass/energy out continuously The mass/energy that is spit out of a white hole drops back into it eventually. This is because of extreme space time curvature around the white hole Ironically this extreme space time curvature of the space around a white hole is caused by the huge mass/energy packed in the white hole Because of continuously spitting mass/energy which keeps...
Back
Top